15
Aug

Regency Project Runway

A. Walking Dress, 1809

Lady B: Who is hosting the ball today? Let me consult my diary. Hmm. Miss Neville. If she doesn’t arrive in five minutes I shall send a footman round to Lady Sarah MacLean for an emergency appearance. She is never late.

<squawk> No lobster patties for Miranda <squawk>

[Miranda rushes in, sticking pins into her hair]. I’m here, I’m here. So sorry Lady B. I’ve been busy with revisions.

Lady B: The other ladies manage to perform their hostess duties and finish their books. Look at Lady Sarah. She has four books to write but she’s always on time. I have a mind to give her all your dates. I suppose you’ve been wasting time reading indecent novels again.

B. Pelisse Dress of Autumn, 1810

Miranda: No, really, I haven’t. I’ve been working hard. [Lady B raises an eyebrow] All right, I admit it. I was catching up with Project Runway on television.

Lady B: Television? Project Runway? Pray, explain yourself.

Miranda: Err… [considers, and discards, the notion of explaining television to Lady B] Project Runway is a competition for fashion designers.

Lady B: Do you mean seamstresses?

Miranda: I suppose so, though many of them are men.

Lady B: Male seamstresses! How very novel. What form does this competition take?

Miranda: Each week, the seamstresses have to make a look – er create an ensemble – according to certain rules. For example, they might have to design a bathing costume, or a uniform for an airline stewardess.

Lady B: What’s that?

C. Evening Dress, 1811

Miranda: [Muttters] This is harder than I thought. [to Lady B] A sort of female footman.

Lady B: Female servants could wear livery, but they wouldn’t be able to show their legs.

Miranda: You’d be surprised.

Lady B: And do these seamstresses have access to the best silk warehouses?

Miranda: When they are lucky they get to go to Mood, an excellent establishment. But sometimes they have to make the clothing out of very odd materials, such as they might find at a greengrocer or a stationer’s, or, most recently, a shop for pet supplies.

<squawk>

It’s all right Albert. They weren’t allowed to touch the animals.

Lady B:  How are these gowns displayed?

Miranda: The designers fit them on models – very beautiful girls.

D. Evening Dress, 1812

Lady B: You shock me, Miranda. Since many of these “designers” are men, it sounds most improper.

Miranda: It’s all right, Lady B. The majority of them are not interested in women that way, if you know what I mean.

Lady B: I do. My cousin’s sister-in-law’s niece married William Beckford, but we don’t talk about it.

Miranda: Besides, most of the models are much taller than the male designers, well over six feet tall.

Lady B: Good heavens! Giantesses. It must take a good deal of cloth to cover them.

Miranda: No, they are all very thin.

Lady B:  Emaciated giantesses. Poor dears, we must invite them here and feed them some supper.
<squawk> Not the lobster patties <squawk>

E. Evening Dress, 1812

Miranda: Once the designers have completed their looks, the models display them in front of the judges. The best gown is named the winner. The one deemed the worst dressed is sent home.

Lady B: Sounds like rather like Almack’s. Who are these judges?

Miranda: You’ve got something there, Lady B. The judge bear a distinct resemblance to the Patronesses. Fraulein Heidi Klum could be Princess Esterhazy. Señora Nina Garcia has much in common with Mrs. Drummond-Burrell, and Mr. Michael Kors is a dead wringer for Lady Jersey, if she were male and had a suntan.

Lady B: Almack’s! No wonder the poor dears are starving! There’s never anything worth eating there.

F. Morning Dress, 1812

Miranda: [Aside] Almack’s refreshments, the Regency equivalent of Diet Coke and cigarettes.

Lady B: Do the seamstresses have any assistants? It’s quite difficult to make a gown in one day.

Miranda: They do it alone, but they have advice from Mr. Tim Gunn, who’s a bit like Mr. Brummell, only much nicer.

Lady B: Miranda! You’re blushing.

Miranda: I must confess, Lady B, I have quite the tendre for Mr. Gunn. Unfortunately he isn’t interested in ladies, either.

Lady B: It all sounds very interesting. I’d like to be a judge myself.

Miranda: They have a guest judge every week. Sometimes an established seamstress, sometimes an actress, and sometimes a socialite … er a member of the ton.

Lady B: Splendid. Arrange it for me Miranda. I wish to be a judge on Project Runway. And darling Albert shall help me. He has exquisite taste and always knows what goes best with my peacock gloves.

G. Walking Dress, 1816

And so, ladies and gentlemen, I bring you Regency Project Runway. Candice Hern (check out her wonderful traditional Regencies, now reissued as ebooks), whose website is a fabulous resource for Regency history and artifacts, was kind enough to scan some particular outrageous examples from her collection of fashion plates. For non PR watchers, the judges on the show usually chose a top three and a bottom three. If you can pick a worthy winner from this lot, good luck. I invite you to nominate the three worst, and your candidate for being Aufed (For the uninitiated, a reference to Heidi Klum’s traditional Auf Wiedersehn to the loser). Scathing comments, another Project Runway tradition, are encouraged. (Also, I’m dying to hear who you think is going to win this year’s competition. Anya? Anthony? Oliver?)

Lady B, with the help of our commenters, will deliver the Auf  on Wednesday.

H. Carriage Dress 1816

I. Carriage Costume, 1816

J. Court Dress 1820

K. Evening Dress, 1812

Under miranda, Regency Project Runway


  1. Aug 15, 2011
    12:56 pm

    Loved this, Miranda!

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      2:50 pm

      Thanks for visiting, Vicky

    • Lady Heliotrope Beaufetheringstone
      Aug 15, 2011
      6:20 pm

      Miss Dreiling, I believe you might like to join the conversation below…something about “Regency The Bachelor?” I haven’t any idea what they’re discussing…after all, it is The Regency, and there are far too many bachelors roaming around in need of wives, if you ask me.

      • Miranda Neville
        Aug 15, 2011
        7:12 pm

        Too many bachelors, Lady B? Don’t you realize we need them for our books, or the lot of us would be out of a job and The Ballroom woefully silent. May the supply never fail.

  2. Lady Heliotrope Beaufetheringstone
    Aug 15, 2011
    1:05 pm

    Late or no, Miss Neville. You are certainly diverting.

    I confess, I am quite disturbed by these terrors, and I should like to send every one of these unfortunate girls to my seamstress.

    I do rather care for dress K. I’ve a penchant for feathered headdresses, as you know, and that one has a bit of a je ne sais quoi, as the Frenchies say.

    I am shocked, however, that the guests have not raised an eyebrow at frock C. It’s hard to imagine where to begin with this one…the color? The hideous, pointed shawl that makes it appear as though the poor girl has been mounted from behind by an enormous centipede? The disastrous detailing on the decolletage? Come to think of it, the disastrous, oddly corseted decolletage all-told? Did the girl have some kind of unfortunate accident?

    lba1010.jpg

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      2:54 pm

      Lady B, with your utterly a propos comments you demonstrate perfect taste. As for “mounted from behind by an enormous centipede,” that’s one for the annals.

      You have the presence to carry off plumes that overwhelm lesser mortals (like the “model” of dress K).


    • Aug 16, 2011
      1:25 am
      eliyanti

      i love this pic ^^

  3. Sabrina Darby
    Aug 15, 2011
    1:32 pm

    Love this, Miranda. I have to agree with Lady B, that K is quite nice. My favorite colors really.

    G is rather nice as well, but wouldn’t go well with my complexion.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      2:56 pm

      You’d look stunning in K, Sabrina, though I might leave the shawl at home.

      • Sabrina Darby
        Aug 15, 2011
        5:18 pm

        Lol. I’d likely leave the feather too. And raise the waistline a bit. And…

        But I love the colors.


  4. Aug 15, 2011
    1:43 pm
    Kat

    Oh I do love me some project runway (Anthony is my pick)…. So this should be fun.

    First I will go with what I think are the winning looks, G, I and J. Well-done designers!!!

    G’s walking dress is FIERCE from head to toe love, love, love the muff!!!

    I’s carriage costume is splendid and kudos for doing a two-piece ensemble. The dress is simple and just enough detail is added to the spencer for a beautiful design and the jauntily tied bow adds interest to the bonnet.

    J’s court dress I can see the opulence, it makes me want to touch it. The fine workmanship, and extravagant detail makes me sigh with appreciation. My only criticism is the headpiece. This I believe could be scaled down a bit. The poor girl looks like she is about to topple over.

    My choice for top design goes to G’s walking dress, so well made; the color combo is spot on… from the bonnet to those lovely shoes. Perfect use of accessories I want this outfit!!!!

    Now bottom three designers…Woo is me!!!

    A’s walking dress looks like monk on St. Patrick’s Day. That collar makes our poor model look like she needs a shave. There is nothing nice I can say about this dress.

    B’s Pelisse dress would only be appropriate if she were Prinny’s court Jester. Seriously bad color scheme, for goodness sake the dog is scared let alone the poor girls bosom is trying to escape to the left and right. Disastrous!!

    C’s Evening dress looks like the ugly duckling just hatched. OMG!! Are those two paisley’s upfront or are they pasties to cover the nipples, really??

    Designers its good thing only one is being declared the worst… and that would be A’s walking dress there is just a sad lack of design!!

    That was fun.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      3:00 pm

      Kat: you get extra points for managing to make three of them sound good! And your comments on the bottom three are Runway ready. You deserve to be a guest judge.

      I think A is wearing a veil, not a collar. Either way, as others have noted, she looks like a bearded lady, ready for a freak show.


  5. Aug 15, 2011
    2:44 pm
    Jeanne Miro

    Miranda -

    Your absolutely right! Project Runway is not to be missed. Don’t you just love Tim Gunn and wish he would show up at your house to help you pick-out your emsemble?

    Tim would defineately not pick the following for an outing or a night at Almacs!

    1. Walking Dress, 1809 – unless you’re getting ready to enter a convent.

    2. Pelisse Dress of Autumn, 1810 (unless your Mrs. B and have big tatas.

    3. Evening Dress, 1812 (okay if it’s a masked ball and your suppose to be a milkmaid it might work.

    4. Runner-Up – Carriage Dress, 1816 (the dress was just “too much” and the hat put it over the top).

    So many elegant other ones so why would you possibly pick one of the above?

    Unfortunately my neice Emogen has all of the above in her wardrobe! It won’t surprise you to know it’s her 4th season.

    Lady Hastings

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      3:04 pm

      Evening Dress 1812 (D) has not drawn nearly enough criticism, IMO. An overdressed milkmaid is right. It’s a beast.

      The Pelisse Dress is horrid, but we don’t like to make personal remarks about our fellow guests.

      So sorry about your niece. I’m sure she’s a perfectly lovely girl who just hasn’t met the right gentleman.

    • Lady Heliotrope Beaufetheringstone
      Aug 15, 2011
      6:23 pm

      It’s Lady B to you, Miss Miro. And I feel confident you did not just refer to a portion as my person as “tatas.” Surely I must have misheard.

      Surely.


  6. Aug 15, 2011
    3:06 pm
    Beebs

    Hi Miranda

    Loving today’s blog. I actually quite like dress K but probably without the head-dress. The Auf in my opinion would have to be A for all the reasons already mentioned.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:13 pm

      Thanks Beebs. I haven’t tallied the votes but A may be creeping into the lead for the Auf.


  7. Aug 15, 2011
    4:11 pm
    Antonia

    I wonder how a Project Runway-inspired historical romance would look like. We’ve had The Bachelor done Regency style. It might be fun. :)


    • Aug 15, 2011
      4:19 pm
      Lady Susan

      Bachelor done Regency Style. I guess the 25 beautiful women would be all the debutantes. The Rose Ceremony could be Almacks. All that ratafia flowing……After that it is a free for all.

      • Miranda Neville
        Aug 15, 2011
        7:14 pm

        Lady B is right. We need Miss Dreiling or Miss Olivia Parker to comment on this.

  8. Sabrina Darby
    Aug 15, 2011
    5:25 pm

    I love all of the comments–so deliciously scathing!

    I wonder if anyone ever truly wore some of those hideous pictures, or if they were more concept drawings, the way haute couture today can be?

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:14 pm

      One has to hope that the accessories, at least, are editorial – and the stylist should be Aufed.


  9. Aug 15, 2011
    6:27 pm

    Much like I sometimes scratch my head over the judge’s picks in the real Project Runway (still flummoxed over Mondo’s loss to uber-bland Gretchen last year), I am stunned that several of you actually LIKE some of these Regency fashions. Hey, I picked threse prints because there are ghastly! But to each her own, I suppose. Maybe there actually were Regency women who wore them and thought they looked fabulous.

    I see lots of votes for Dess K, for example. Excuse me, but how does anyone even notice the dress with those plumes sprouting into space?

    The court dress (J) is also mentioned now and then. I will agree that the dress is lovely. In fact, this was from the first year that hoops were no longer required at court. I have always assumed that this lady transferred all the bulk of the old hoops to her head. Yes, white ostrich feathers were a requirement of court dress, but I doubt anyone meant for an entire flock (or is it herd?) of the giant birds to be plopped on one’s head.

    As for G, which many seem to like, look more closely at that ridiculous Elizabethan ruff, a hat that scrapes the ceiling, the odd shoulders, and a muff the size of Texas. I mean … seriously?

    The carriage costume (Dress I) is also undeserving, IMO, of any praise. Did no one notice the Dungeness crab crawling up her bonnet?

    And one has to wonder about dress I — as well as A, F and H — and how unflatteringly large they make the model look. One thing Nina and Heidi would never allow is an outfit that makes even the size 0 models look fat.

    Send them all home, I say!

    • Sabrina Darby
      Aug 15, 2011
      6:51 pm

      You chose very well!

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:17 pm

      Since the judges have to come with a Top Three, however difficult, one must search for good elements in the most misguided of ensembles. I do think a well-wielded pair of shears could make several of these looks bearable.

      Meanwhile, here’s a larger view of H so that viewers can appreciate the full horror.
      ack0316.jpg


  10. Aug 15, 2011
    6:31 pm

    Miranda, great fun! The last time I watched PR was when Christian won. Talk about a flamboyant character!

    The first three plates get my vote. I had to squint hard to identify the gender in plate 1. The model rather looks like she’s about to preside over a church service.

    Plate 2–didn’t know Batman’s Joker existed in the Regency.

    Plate 3–looks painful, in an elegant sort of way.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:19 pm

      Fierce! Tracey.

      A might well win an ecclesiastical challenge – for priests in drag. LOL on Batman’s Joker. (We love Batman references at The Ballroom)


  11. Aug 15, 2011
    6:32 pm
    Vivian Davis

    What a delicious contest! and what a stellar collection of fashion plates on which to exercise our wit. The hat makes H look appropriate for a particularly stylish professoress. Ensemble I strikes me as quite an accurate depiction of Napoleon in drag. I can’t quite parse out to what extent it’s the model and to what extent the gown. And his bosoms are particularly akimbo, though that seems to be the style (B, C and E have the same trait). But speaking of bosoms, my vote for Auffing goes to Ensemble C because I can’t take my eyes off the damsel’s frontispieces. What are those decorations? What ARE they? Has someone sewn yellow ornamental peppers to the bodice? I won’t comment on Ensemble D. I couldn’t possibly surpass what’s already been said.

    Charming fun. :)

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:22 pm

      “Napoleon in drag” – spew. Those yellow things on C’s bosom are really something, aren’t they?

  12. Gaelen Foley
    Aug 15, 2011
    6:38 pm

    So sorry, my lovelies, I would choose, but I have gone blind from these horrors and have fainted dead away…

    Gaelen, who is in no danger of turning into an emaciated giantess under any circumstances…

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      7:24 pm

      Quick, send a footman for some smelling salts. We can’t have the lovely Miss Foley expire before her Thursday post.

  13. Gaelen Foley
    Aug 15, 2011
    6:44 pm

    Sending a curtsey to Lady Candice Hern for so generously sharing these with us. Merci, madame!


  14. Aug 15, 2011
    7:00 pm
    Estela Williams

    Oh my gosh… I loved the fashion back then. I say the more over the top the better, but with that said….

    Let me tell you, first, the 3 that were on the bottom for me….
    H. Carriage Dress 1816…. I don’t understand this look. Is she a professor? Is she a graduating? This is a bad case of over embellishing… I mean, what’s up with the bows on the hem? Did they think that that would make this dress look feminine? didn’t work!

    D. Evening Dress, 1812… is another confusing mess. Is she Leah with the bun hair? Is she a lady or a maid? And the design makes the model look very top heavy!!

    A. Walking Dress, 1809…. the designer of this dress would be OUT of this Regency Project Runway competition. I laughed so hard when I saw this dress. Is she afraid of the sun? She is SOOOO covered up… and with a veil no doubt!! Hahaha…. I can hear Michael Kors’ voice right now!!

    Now let me tell you the 3 that I did like…
    G. Walking Dress, 1816…. I love the color and the empire cut. I am totally digging the hat and the hand warmer thingy.

    J. Court Dress 1820…. This is what I imagine the dresses to be like in that era. I think it’s very romantic, and I bet the lady wearing this dress would have her dance card filled. My only criticism is her headpiece. It’s like an ostrich sat on her head. I bet her head and neck hurt trying to support that thing.

    K. Evening Dress, 1812… Would be the WINNER of this Regency Project Runway. I would wear this dress NOW. I love the colors… I love the fruffy head piece… I love how daringly low the front is. Absolutely stunning!!

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      11:41 pm

      Wonderful choices, Estela, and wonderfully scathing comments. You made me go an look at D again and you have to wonder what evening occasion this girl is attending. An evening in a beer garden, I think.


  15. Aug 15, 2011
    11:05 pm
    Janet W

    B, C and D … C and D because they so point burning fingers to the bust line. Seriously made me think of some of Madonna’s more outrageous and pointy costumes.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 15, 2011
      11:44 pm

      LOL Janet. Those divided bosoms are so odd. I is something Madonna would wear too, if she was a frump.


  16. Aug 16, 2011
    12:19 am
    Amy Valentini

    As always the humor found here is always a bright point in my day. I do have to say that I am sure that Fraulein Heidi would most understandably ‘Auf ‘ most of these dreadful costumes in a blink of an eye.
    A. what was this woman thinking? AUF!
    B. was this possible a costume from a production of “Alice Through the Looking Glass”? Too strange.
    C. this one had potential but those things accenting her bosom look more like a coroner’s doing than a seamstress.
    D. This one, if worn by a woman with a more delicate figure, might have potential. This model looks like she might have some sort of swelling that perhaps her physician should examine.
    E. Is that a ladder to her bosom on the front? Such paleness cannot be flattering to even the palest of complexions.
    F. This morning dress would certainly send a husband scurrying for the office or club rather than desiring to stay and keep company longer with his beloved.
    G. Awww, now this is the one. It’s feminine, classic and elegant. Any lady would gladly be seen strolling in the park wearing this as would her gentleman be glad she’s on his arm.
    H. Is this woman dressing in an attempt to impress the scholars? Whatever is the purpose of that hat? Jester, perhaps.
    I. I rather like this ensemble although I think she must have extremely long heavy arms or is it the bunching that makes them appear so?
    J. Is she wearing the drapery from the drawing room?
    K. Elegant, figure flattering and I even enjoy the color. I would however prefer a more reserved feather upon her head.
    Lady B. and Miss Miranda, thank you for the fun.

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 16, 2011
      5:34 pm

      Excellent analysis, Amy. Lady B will certainly take your comments into consideration when she makes the final decision about the Auf.


  17. Aug 16, 2011
    1:14 pm

    As a huge huge PR fan, I’m loving this contest! (BTW, agree with outrage on insipid nouveau-hippie designs being last season’s winner.) Thought last week’s stilt-model contest interesting, agree with winner tho I thought the hugely fun mock matador much more interesting than the chiffon pants and shirt preferred by the judges. Perhaps that ensemble looked better live?

    As for this contest, it appears lady A wishes to indulge in a bit of intrigue by going out dressed as a coachman. But the ensemble truly deserving of an AUF must be C, who appears to have sewn gold codpieces over her bosom. Really, does she not realize that codpieces are so very TUDOR?

    Thank you, kind ladies, for providing a light moment (and some interim fun until this week’s PR.)

    • Miranda Neville
      Aug 16, 2011
      5:36 pm

      I couldn’t understand why the judges liked that dowdy chiffon number, Julia, even without the unbelievable hair. I picked it for bottom three. Oh well, it wouldn’t be Project Runway without the head scratching decisions. Gretchen! Really?


  18. Aug 16, 2011
    5:02 pm
    jody

    I don’t think many of these were very flattering for all but the young miss with a slender shilouette, especially those with detailing on or near the bosum. Yikes ! But here are my choices though I would loose most of the headpeices but then I am am tall at 5’10 and wouldn’t want the extra height.

    Worst A E H Best G J K


  19. Jan 5, 2012
    7:23 pm

    [...] I am the guest judge on Project Runway I have to send someone home. Dear me, how sad.  Unlike the Patronesses of a certain establishment [...]


  20. Feb 3, 2012
    4:33 am

    Say, you got a nice blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.


  21. Feb 7, 2012
    1:45 am

    Great article.Really thank you! Awesome.


  22. Jul 14, 2012
    8:36 am

    [...] Tessa warms to the game: And Regency Project Runway! [...]

Leave a Reply

You can add images to your comment by clicking here.

The Next Set

Join us Mondays and Thursdays for the ball, and Saturdays for Lady B's Saturday Salon!

The Authors

Find Us

Twitter Facebook RSS Feed

Search

Categories

Tags

Archives

Links Out

Meta

Dance Card

At the Duke’s Wedding

Miranda Neville & Katharine Ashe
Available now

At the Duke's Wedding

Any Duchess Will Do

Tessa Dare
Available now

Any Duchess Will Do

Let It Be Me

Kate Noble
Available now

Let It Be Me

The Ashford Affair

Lauren Willig
Available now

The Ashford Affair

How To Marry a Highlander

Katharine Ashe
Coming July 30, 2013

How To Marry a Highlander

One Good Earl Deserves A Lover

Sarah MacLean
Available now

One Good Earl Deserves a Lover

Entry-Level Mistress

Sabrina Darby
Available Now

Entry Level Mistress