Jan
Saturday Salon ~ Historical Inspiration: The Count of Monte Cristo (Movie, 2002)
One of the great advantages of writing historical romance fiction is that it tends to age better than contemporary-set stories. The historical tales, I think, have a longer shelf life because they don’t have all the contemporary-world cues like current fashions, buzzwords, and the passing tech fads of the day, that eventually make a story feel dated.
If The Count of Monte Cristo, (Touchstone Pictures, 2002) is any example, this is clearly just as true of movies as it is of books. This film is now ten years old and is as fresh and beautiful a movie as ever. (As one wit online quipped: “Dumbledore teaches Jesus swordfighting.” Who could resist that??)
I was lucky enough to catch it on the Ovation Channel the other day when I was worn out from my book deadline, and the Regency-era scenes gave me all the writing mojo I needed to get going on the final push to finish my book. Check out the trailer:
REASONS TO WATCH OR WATCH AGAIN:
1. It has a happy ending. (I don’t know about you, but I run from tragic endings like the plague.)
2. It starts in a wonderfully rendered world of 1814 with Napoleon on Elba. (Although those cliffs are apparently County Wicklow, as it was filmed in Ireland!)
3. The gorgeous Jim Cavaziel. Of course, you may feel a little weird as I did, admiring his hotness as Edmond Dantes after seeing him as Jesus in the Passion of the Christ–! But as the Count, this is a guy who knows how to make an entrance. You fall in love with his vulnerability as he’s trying to wrap his mind about being unjustly imprisoned through the treachery of his so-called friend. Later, when he’s turned into a rich badass, I love his luxurious greatcoat thing that he wears throughout the second half of the movie. I gotta say he would fit right into the Inferno Club. *g*
4. Wonderful historical details throughout… the carriages, the furniture, the weapons, THE CLOTHES… speaking of which, check out this Six Degrees of Separation about the costumes used in this movie. I had no idea these Regency costumes got passed around so much in the entertainment world. Who knew??
From http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0245844/trivia:
The white polka dot dress with ornate floral pattern on the bodice that Dagmara Dominczyk (Mercedès Iguanada) wears at the office of Monsieur Villefort is the same costume Julia Sawalha (Lydia Bennet) wears while observing Wickham horse riding in Pride and Prejudice, and Ruby Bentall (Mary Bennet) wears to the Meryton Assembly Ball in Lost in Austen.Share this Hide options
The beige dress with paisley bodice worn by an extra on the Marseilles wharf early in the film is the same costume Sabina Franklyn (Jane Bennet) wears at Longbourn in Pride and Prejudice, Rachel Fielding (Mrs. Benson) wears in Princess Caraboo, Julie Cox (Annabella Milbanke) wears to read Byron’s poetry book in Byron, and Freema Agyeman (Tattycoram) wears on the Marseilles wharf in Little Dorrit. The same costume is also worn by a guest at Fanny’s wedding in Miss Austen Regrets.The red paisley waistcoat Luis Guzmán (Jacopo) wears in the final scene is the same costume Chris Gorell Barnes wears in The Regency House Party, Dan Stevens (Edward Ferrars) wears for Edward’s arrival at Norland in Sense & Sensibility, and JJ Feild (Fred Garland) wears in The Shadow in the North.Share thisThe green and brown silk gown Helen McCrory (Valentina Villefort) wears to Albert’s party is the same gown Natasha Little (Augusta Leigh) wears when Byron escorts her to the ball in Byron, and Victoria Hopkins wears on the lawn with Lisa Braund in The Regency House Party.
5. Swordplay, fight scenes, derring-do… what you always wished you could see Mr. Darcy do to Wickham, but of course, The Jane would never show such a thing. Alexandre Dumas pere does. Huzzah!

6. One of the things I love about this story (which BTW was said to be Mark Twain’s favorite book) is the spiritual dimension it goes into as a counterpoint to its physical vigor. God comes up a lot as Edmond Dantes tries to understand why this injustice has befallen him and what he’s going to do about it. Spiritual ideas are further explored when he befriends an elderly priest in prison. Played by the great Richard Harris, Abbe Faria is a true Rennaissance man, a priest, scholar and former soldier, who gives the illiterate Dantes an education worthy of a gentleman while in prison. It is also the Abbe who clues Dantes in to the location of the treasure that will allow him to transform himself into the Count of Monte Cristo.
I really appreciate this movie because it is such an inspiration to me personally in the kinds of stories I like to write. We are fortunate that Hollywood saw fit to make so many beautiful Jane Austen movies in recent years, but my personal hankering in Regency tales involves more action/adventure and danger/derring-do than the kinds of stories Austen was interested in telling ~ throw in an earnest spiritual search ~ crashing highs and lows of emotion ~ and I’m in heaven. The Jane movies (Colin Firth et al) strike me more like soft, gentle watercolors full of charm and subtle wit, whereas the Count of Monte Cristo comes at us with bold colors and strong contrasts of dark and light. That’s the kind of story that helps to put me in touch with what I want to achieve in my own small way as a writer.
What movies inspire you? Whether period movies or writer-themed movies…is there a go-to film that you watch when you need to remember the “mood” or “feel” of what you’re doing as a writer? Or just inspire you about life?














Jan 14, 2012
2:28 am
Hi Gaelen, that was a really nice tribute to THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO and Alexandre Dumas, thanks for sharing that. Interesting trivia about the clothes. I hope they are all well washed in between. : )
I love period pieces – period! Sometimes I’m in the mood for the genteelness of an Austen film and other times I’m in a THREE MUSKETEERS mood … I started reading Dumas’ books when I was about 12 and fell in love with it all. My hubby always says he would feel comfortable being a young man during the 1930′s and 40′s … I think I must have lived in late 1700′s to early 1800′s in Europe or on the high seas – give me an Errol Flynn swashbuckler and my imagination soars! I’m going to have to watch some sword action tomorrow, I think, while doing chores. Adieu, cherie! : )
Jan 14, 2012
10:41 am
You make a very good point (as always) Miss Amy. Sometimes you feel like a nut or a swordfight, sometimes you don’t. (LAME-O olk). It’s early, ha ha. Need more coffee. .. lol
Jan 14, 2012
12:16 pm
LOL!! After I wrote that (very late last night) I thought about the ‘three musketeers mood’ part and thought of the same thing!! Wondered if anyone would catch the silliness. Thanks for being silly, Lady Gaelen! <3
Jan 14, 2012
7:43 am
Wonderful book, film, and blog post : )
I am a huge fan of Dumas! My mother and I loved the 1973 film version of “The Three Musketeers”, which starred Michael York as “d’Artagnan”, Oliver Reed as “Athos”, Frank Finlay as “Porthos”, and Richard Chamberlain as “Aramis”. The stellar supporting cast included Charlton Heston, Faye Dunaway, Christopher Lee, and Racquel Welch. When Mama and I agreed on anything, it had to be something special! We also loved the 1974 sequel, “The Four Musketeers” : )
Jan 14, 2012
10:42 am
Hi Virginia! Wow, you’ve given me some good tips for new ones for me to see. I haven’t seen either of those older ones from the 70′s. Thanks for the tip, and glad you enjoyed the post!

Gaelen
Jan 14, 2012
12:19 pm
Definitely, see those Gaelen, they beat the bejeebers out of the newer ones. I thought Oliver Reed was strangely sexy in a rough, gruff sorta way and Faye Dunaway was deliciously evil to Raquel Welch’s clumsy innocence!!
Jan 14, 2012
10:40 am
Great post Gaelen!
I confess I have never read The Count of Monte Cristo, but it is a wonderful story with a lot of depth and thought provoking themes-especially the spiritual ones you mentioned. It wasn’t up to Edmond to exact vengenance for the injustices done to him-he must trust in God to even the score for him. And I’m with you on the Henry Cavaziel. YUMMY!
One movie that always inspires me is The American President. That scene in the end when Michael Douglas gives that passionate speech about patriotism, the First Amendment, and what it means to be an American gets me everytime. Of course, it also helps that I’m a huge political junkie in real life anyway, lol.
I also love Amazing Grace, starring Ioan Gruffud as William Wilberforce, the man who spearheaded to effort to end the slave trade in the British Empire. What an inspiring story about a man who fights for what he believes is right in the face of seemingly insurmountable obstacles.
Jan 14, 2012
10:44 am
Hi Lisa! Thanks for the great feedback. I haven’t seen Am. Pres. but now you’ve made me want to add it to my DVR queue. I always enjoy Michael Douglas.
We saw Amazing Grace recently, missed it when it was new, and WOW i was blown away by it. We need some more guys like that to show up in politics today, eh? Such courage. Amazing, indeed!
Have a great day and thanks for stopping by! Always nice to see ya here.

Gaelen
Jan 14, 2012
11:09 am
I love Emma Thompson’s Sense & Sensibility. Before and really since Dan Steven’s version of S&S, it has been the go to movie. The day my father died, I needed something to get my mind off my troubles, so I put on this movie. I had to give a pained laugh when I did mental lapse at how the movie began – with Elinor & Marianne’s father dying. But, it did help me in time of need.
I just love the story of the sisters. I have often thought of myself a little like Marianne Dashwood. I love bad boys and have always adored Willoughby (who can’t love him when he is played by Greg Wise?) and have gotten strange looks from Janeites and other Costume Drama lovers. Out of all Jane Austen’s novels, I would place it number one with Persuasion as number 2.
Other movies that are “go to” movies are Wuthering Heights (also have a thing for Heathcliff), North & South (Richard Armitage, may I say more?), Master & Commander (I love the ships! Russ Crowe isn’t bad either) and Pirates of the Carribean (Orlando Bloom, Johnny Depp and I just love the story of it).
I can’t believe it has been 10 years since Count of Monte Cristo has been made. I, too, love this movie. I adored Richard Chamberlain’s version, but Jim Cavarziel’s version tops this. It does have a little bit of everything and Guy Pierce isn’t bad to look at either.
Jan 14, 2012
4:00 pm
Hi Jamie,
Oh, wow, you’re a brave woman, watching S&S while you were in the same sitch as the sisters. I think we have the same tastes in movies!! Brilliant minds obviously think alike. *g* I got a great kick out of the re-think of Willoughby in Lost in Austen. Very interesting twist on who the real good guy was, no?? Funny.
I don’t know about Guy Pierce though. He’s been a great villain several times over, hasn’t he? that he scares me now, LOL.
Gaelen
Jan 14, 2012
11:20 am
I can’t believe I haven’t seen this version! That will be remedied immediately! And I agree, I adore swashbuckling stories.
Oh and actually, reading up in the comments, I still haven’t seen Amazing Grace. I think I’m going to have to wrench back control of the Netflix list in my home.
Jan 14, 2012
4:05 pm
Sabrina, you’re in for a treat! Huzzah!!!
Jan 14, 2012
12:35 pm
Not only do I have a huge to be read list, my to be viewed list is getting larger. Loved the Count of Monte Cristo when it first came out, for the history of course. The men are some of the best eye candy around. I don’t watch movies, I listen to them so I can do housework. But there are times I will plop down on the couch and become engrossed in the movie. This is all under the guise of looking for loose change between the cushions. Did find my safety deposit key there!
I like movies set way back in history, they tell a greater story. They don’t seem so much like fiction as current movies do. I can transport myself back into that time and get the feel f being at a ball or witnessing a sword fight.
I saw Jane Eyre last night and will be adding it to my collection. Since I am not a big fan of renting movies or direct streaming, I have ended up with huge DVD collection.
Sounds like the DVD player needs to be dusted and it has P&P in it. Collin Firth is calling my name…
Jan 14, 2012
4:05 pm
That is a great point about the high stakes in so many period pieces. (Not just because they cost so many more millions for the studios to make, har har.) To find that kind of high stakes in contemp movies, you need to look at thrillers, usually, which have a totally different dynamic.
Interesting.. and nice to see ya, Susan!
Jan 14, 2012
1:21 pm
The 2002 version of “The Count of Monte Cristo” is one of my favorite moves. Have it on DVD and watch it everytime I catch it on TV. Have you seen “Firelight” with Sophie Marceau? Takes my breath away. Such a powerful and passionate movie. Difficult to find on DVD, but I know Netflix has it. A must see!
P.S. Also agree with the 1973 version of “The Three Musketeers.” Puts any of the newer versions to shame.
Jan 14, 2012
4:02 pm
I haven’t seen Firelight, but I love Sophie Marceau! Didn’t she play Anna Karenina a few years back opposite my top demigod, Sean Bean??
I’ll have to track that one down–thanks!
Gaelen
Jan 14, 2012
8:00 pm
She did play Anna Karenina and was also the French Queen in “Braveheart.” Don’t delay watching “Firelight,” you won’t be disappointed.
Jan 14, 2012
3:33 pm
I love love love this movie, Gaelen, for many of the reasons you list–including the lovely lovely Jim Caveziel! Thanks for reminding me that I haven’t seen it in an age! xoxo
Jan 14, 2012
4:03 pm
I know!!! Can you believe it’s 10 years since it first came out? Sheesh.
I googled top contemporary romantic comedies of 2002 to see how dated they had become. Some top choices were Maid in Manhattan with Jaylo, and one of my dh’s all time fave funnies, Shallow Hal.
Jan 14, 2012
7:10 pm
Ten years? Really? I only saw it once and clearly it’s time for a review. Remember that it was gorgeous. I think my favorite historical movie may be Amadeus. Not a happy ending, of course. I weep buckets at the end but then it’s a (kind of) true story and real life does end badly. In fiction it’s unforgivable! Mozart is definitely one of my top 5 favorite people in history.
Jan 14, 2012
11:24 pm
One of my favorite period piece movies is Stage Beauty with Clair Danes and Billy Crudup. It didn’t get a lot of notice and to be honest I don’t even know how historically accurate it all is (majority of characters were real people), but it takes place in the mid-seventeenth century when women wanted to start acting the female roles in plays. One of my favorite scenes in the movie is when Billy Crudup is telling Clair Danes he likes being the woman because they do everything beautifully and they even die pretty (meaning they don’t even put up a fight). This statement annoys Clair and she yells at him saying, “No woman would die like that, a woman would fight!” I always loved that part because it’s so true. Oh, I forgot to mention the best part of it- Rupert Everett plays King Charles II. It really is a fun movie to watch, comedy, drama, romance.
I pretty much love all historical dramas that have some form of romance in them. They’re so rare these days.
Jan 15, 2012
9:03 pm
Hi Gaelen,
I agree with Virginia and my favorite is The Three Musketeers. I must admit that got me “hooked” on swashbuckling heros was growing up watching the TV version of The Three Musketeers in the 1950′s!
Of course I pretended to be present there with them with my sword swishing in the air and going after the “bad guys”. I had two older sisters but all the children my age in the neighborhood were boys so I was the daughter in the family who played kickball with the boys and I hated dolls!
Fortunately for my husband I overcame my being a tomboy and in my teenage years I grew to appreciate the “finer” things of being a girl. The one thing that I retained is that it taught me at an early age to stand up for myself in a male environment.
I blame my tomboy days on my Dad for making me his “fishing buddy” when I was growing up (actually that meant doing more rowing than fishing)! Now if he had wanted to teach me how to fight with a sword that would have been something I looked forward to!