Feb
A White House Romance
As I enter the ballroom today, Lady B approaches me at one. She’s walking with purpose, and a curious gleam shines in her eye.
Miss Dare, I hear that this is another of those Colonial holidays.
Yes, indeed, Lady B. It’s Presidents’ Day.
Presidents. Hm. The American form of government may be more democratic, but it strikes me as decidedly less romantic. No princes. No dukes. No knights. Somehow, I doubt that young ladies lay their heads to their pillows each night and dream of one day marrying a senator.
You may be right, Lady B. And that’s no doubt one reason why we Americans make such liberal use of England as a setting in our romance novels. But American history has found room for a love story or two. Thus far, only one president has been married in the White House, but the story was like something straight out of a Regency romance.
Indeed? Details, Miss Dare. Pictures, or it didn’t happen.
Here’s a picture!

Mr. and Mrs. President.
Grover Cleveland was in his late 40s when he became president, and he was, as they say, a confirmed bachelor. Actually, you could even say he was a bit of a rake–he’d admitted to fathering a child out of wedlock. After he was elected, he lived in the White House with his bluestocking sister, a scholar who wrote books on George Eliot and St. Augustine and chafed under the social restrictions of the day.
This sister sounds like she’d make an interesting heroine in her own right. Did Mr. Cleveland marry one of her bluestocking friends?
No, President Cleveland fell in love with his ward, Frances Folsom, a woman 27 years his junior.
Twenty-seven years old?

Frances Folsom Cleveland
No, twenty-seven years youngerthan he. She was only 21 when they married, and he’d known her since her infancy. Her father and Grover Cleveland were business partners, and Mr. Cleveland became executor of Mr. Folsom’s will when he died. Though he was never Frances’ legal guardian, he was very involved in supervising her upbringing and education (which included stints at charming-sounding institutions such as “Madame Brecker’s French Kindergarten” and “Miss Bissell’s School for Young Ladies”). But it wasn’t until Frances reached her late teens that Mr. Cleveland’s regard transformed from beneficent guardianship to courtly love. He proposed marriage in 1885, shortly after Frances had finished her studies at Wells College.
My goodness. A proposal of marriage from the President of the United States. That must have come as a shock.
To her mother, it certainly did–or at least, that’s what was rumored. Gossip was that Mrs. Emma Folsom was thinking the President might propose marriage to her.
Scandal!
Scandal was precisely what President Cleveland feared. To delay speculation, he sent his fiance on a tour of Europe for most of the following year–for finishing, cultural exposure, and–of course–shopping. When they married in 1886, he announced the White House wedding less than a week in advance, to avoid press attention as much as possible.
Albert: <SQUAWK>Paparazzi!<SQUAWK>
Exactly, Albert. He knew the reporters would hound them, and he was right. When they left on a train for their mountain honeymoon, a second train full of reporters followed and set up camp. They cataloged the newlyweds’ every move for the public.
"I'm President Cleveland, and I approve this appliance."
But contrary to President Cleveland’s concerns, the public wasn’t scandalized. Rather, the older bachelor’s obvious affection for his young, charming, vivacious bride endeared him to the American public. The first couple became an object of much fascination. Frances was a large part of his reelection campaign, due to her popularity. They appeared everywhere, on everything. Here they are, in a sewing machine ad.
What a remarkable story, Miss Dare.
Isn’t it? Not just a remarkable story, but one with a remarkable heroine. I’m just stunned, trying to imagine what it must be like to be twenty-one years old, preparing not only to marry a man nearly three decades your senior, but the President of the United States! What an enormous amount of pressure Frances must have felt. And yet she thrived in the role of First Lady and remained devoted to her husband until his death. She must have been a very remarkable woman indeed.
What do you think of May/December romances, in fiction? Any favorites to mention in the comments?
Do you have a favorite First Lady?











Feb 20, 2012
1:54 am
What a nice tribute for President’s Day, Tessa, thanks for a delightful bit of history. I collect the Christmas White House ornaments and the one depicting this marriage is one of my absolute favorites.
Don’t think I have a fave First Lady but as to May/Dec romances, I think we’re kind of used to them if we read a lot of historicals since it wasn’t unusual for that kind of romance. Even my grandfather was thirty when he married my grandmother who was only nineteen. If two people are in love, should an age difference matter? Although, I have to admit that I’d personally think twice about a man almost 30 years older. Now I might be interested in fooling around with a man 30 years younger. ; )
Feb 20, 2012
11:19 am
A collection of Christmas White House ornaments sounds so neat, Amy! What a cool thing to collect–your tree must be very patriotic indeed!
Feb 20, 2012
11:27 am
I agree! What a fun thing to collect!
And Amy, I totally feel the same about the May/December romances — they feel more natural in historicals for some reason. I would imagine, from a purely practical standpoint, a man might want a young wife because of the physical strains and risks of childbearing in those times. Today, it’s much easier and safer for women to have children into their 30s and 40s. Thankfully!
Feb 20, 2012
7:43 am
I think that in general romance writers try to avoid the May/December romances which is why you get so many stories about bluestocking spinsters and governesses. But I like the ones with an age gap because it seems a bit more realistic for the period and also it adds another dimension to the difficulties they have to get over in order to understand one another’s perspective because there is no doubt that with an age gap will always come a different outlook on life.
My 2 favourite May/Decembers that come to mind are Josie and Mayne in Eloisa James’ Pleasure for Pleasure and Horry and Rule in Georgette Heyer’s Convenient Marriage.
Feb 20, 2012
11:20 am
Oh, I’m totally with you, Lucifer’s Lady! I love Josie and Mayne! They’re my very very favorite!
Feb 20, 2012
11:28 am
Me too! Although when I realize the “December” half of that May/December romance was younger than me… I wilt a little.
One of my recent favorites was Julie Anne Long’s What I Did for a Duke.
Feb 20, 2012
9:38 am
The one thing I always loved about our Presidents and their First Ladies from the past is that they seem to actually marry for love.
I don’t really have a favorite, but I always thought Mary Todd Lincoln was interesting. She apparently was very scandalous with low cut bodices and liked wearing very bright colors. And people say she was sarcastic. And of course people think she might have suffered from mental illness later on. Regardless, I think she was interesting though.
Feb 20, 2012
11:23 am
Elizabeth, have you seen the Geico commercial with Mary Todd Lincoln? Now every time I think of her, I think of that…and get the giggles:
Feb 20, 2012
5:09 pm
LOL! Yes I have. Too funny. I love those Geico commercials.
Feb 20, 2012
11:31 am
Poor Mary Todd Lincoln had it so rough – losing a husband, and at least one child (I think – if I’m remembering it correctly). I think there’s a general agreement among historians now that she did suffer from mental illness, at least toward the end of her life. But yes, she was a very interesting woman.
In contrast to Frances Cleveland, I recently read that Mary Todd Lincoln actually stayed out of the way during Abraham Lincoln’s campaigning and debating because they were worried her refined and wealthy background would ruin his “man of the people” appeal.
Feb 20, 2012
11:53 am
Thanks for the lovely post, Tessa! That sewing machine ad is amazing.
You’re right, Mary Todd Lincoln outlived three of her four children (and Abe outlived two of them). She and Lincoln had a really turbulent romance–it would make a good romance novel, except that they had so many difficulties and tragedies after their marriage. No HEA for those two.
We have a placemat with Presidents on it–a souvenir from a DC trip I took years ago. My toddler daughter got fond of it and uses it every day, and she likes to ask me questions about the Presidents while she eats. You haven’t really pondered history until you’ve answered questions like “Which President was the silliest?” (My guess was Lincoln.)
Feb 20, 2012
12:05 pm
That placemat sounds like a great idea!
My own children have struggled to bend their minds around what exactly “President” means, and how it’s different from Mayor, Governor, etc. My daughter was just 3 or 4 during the 2008 election, and her questions were hilarious. She knew the names of both candidates (Brocko Bama and John MeCame) and went to the polling place with me to vote. And while we were waiting in line, she dashed up ahead, peaked inside, and came back to me all upset – MOM, THEY’RE NOT THERE!
She thought they’d be at every polling place, I guess, like Santa’s in every mall at Christmas.
Feb 20, 2012
12:17 pm
Cutest. Stories. Ever.
I love civically-minded babies best.
Feb 20, 2012
1:42 pm
*giggle*
Feb 20, 2012
6:19 pm
How adorable!!! That is too cute.
Feb 20, 2012
10:10 am
Wonderful post, Tessa. I knew Cleveland had been married in the White House but not the details. Their story is fascinating. The idea of educating a young woman, forming her into a suitable wife, has a long literary tradition. Moliere’s School for Wives is the best known and there’s at least one English play with a similar plot. Usually in these, the older man who has kept his ward locked up until she’s ready to marry is played for the fool when the girl runs off with a younger man. I assume this did not happen to President C!
Guardian/ward romances can be great – you get that nice frisson of the man being in a position of authority and the heroine upending the status quo. As for age difference, my thinking has evolved. As a teenager, books like Heyer’s Convenient Marriage (mentioned above by LL) and These Old Shades never bothered me. I took seventeen year olds marrying men of 35-45 in my stride, probably because any man over 25 seemed pretty old to me! Now that big an age difference tends to squick me out. I particularly don’t like very young and naive heroines. In this I think I reflect current public opinion. But a lot depends on the maturity level of both characters and, as usual, a good writer can make anything work.
Finally, I don’t have a favorite First Lady. I think they almost all do a very difficult job with grace. I love Michele Obama.
Feb 20, 2012
11:39 am
Miranda, one does wonder how long Grover Cleveland had this marriage in mind. According to some of the articles I read, he never thought of it until she was fully grown, but… yeah. It’s definitely true that he encouraged her to undertake experiences and education that would prepare her for the role of First Lady — especially her Grand Tour — and he definitely had a firm hand in deciding how she would interact and move in society after they were married. Still, it’s hard to imagine that just any 21-year-old would be ready for such a role! Despite his efforts, she must have also been rather a natural.
I think you’re absolutely right that the readership has grown much more accepting of heroines in their 20s, 30s, and even beyond nowadays (yay!), and we don’t see as many May/December pairings for that reason alone. I think I’ve written several couples where the heroine is around 20ish and the hero is around 30ish, but that’s the biggest gap I’ve written – yet.
I too love Michelle Obama and her eating/exercising platform. As a librarian, I also appreciated both Bush First Ladies’ efforts toward literacy and reading.
Feb 20, 2012
1:43 pm
It does have a Pygmalian flavor to it, doesn’t it, Miranda?
Feb 20, 2012
10:27 am
What a wonderful way to commemorate President’s Day Tessa!
Lady Lucifer already mentioned one of my favorite May/December romances, Eloisa’s Pleasure for Pleasure. I believe there is also a bit of an age gap between the Duke of Falconbridge and Genevieve Eversea in JAL’s What I Did For a Duke. When it comes to May/December romances, like Miranda says, depending on the characters involved and the writing, it can definitely work. It also depends on how big of an age gap. If the person you marry is young enough to be your grandchild, that would definitely squick me out.
I think one of my favorite First Ladies would have to be Eleanor Roosevelt. She was one of the first to really utilize her position as First Lady to try to affect positive change on a large scale, and I greatly admire her efforts to advance women’s rights, civil rights, and human rights.
This post also brings to mind one of my favorite movies, The American President. Michael Douglass and Annette Benning were perfect in that movie. I mean, when your first date together is a State Dinner for the President and First Lady of France, that’s a hard act to follow!
Feb 20, 2012
11:29 am
Great movie, Lisa! I love the line where Annette Benning tells the President that he lost her vote. Ouch!
Oh, and I have to agree about Eleanor. Did you know that she served King George V & his queen hotdogs at her house in Upstate NY? They came during the summer, and she (naturally) had them for a cookout! That woman had moxie.
Feb 20, 2012
11:45 am
I *love* that movie, Lisa! It’s so fun. I bet it’ll be on TV somewhere today.
And wow, what an amazing woman Eleanor Roosevelt was. I agree, she is the epitome of what we now want our First Ladies to be–not just a gracious social hostess, but an advocate for social change.
Feb 20, 2012
11:38 am
What a fabulous post, Tessa! Like Miranda, I knew about the wedding, but not the circumstances of the marriage. So fun! (I always liked the idea of Cleveland being a committed single man and raking it up in the White House like the George Clooney of Presidents. Same initials, same personality in my head.)
As for May/December romances, I’m decidedly pro. While I love the spinster heroine, I’m never one to shy away from a story because the heroine is too young. I grew up with Judith McNaught, after all! What is love if not blind?
Feb 20, 2012
11:48 am
Oops! And I didn’t answer your First Lady question! I’m partial to Dolley Madison – Regency First Lady. Dolley is most famous for saving the Stuart portrait of George Washington from fire when the British burned the White House in 1814, but she actually saved much more than that. As the house was burning, she directed an army of servants to save as much historical artifact from it as possible, waiting for the very last moment to leave…only after writing a letter to her sister! That’s badassery.
Feb 20, 2012
6:21 pm
I vote for Dolley, too! And she has pastries named after her. That gets my vote right there.
Feb 20, 2012
11:55 am
LOL, imagining Cleveland as the Clooney of presidents! I’m not sure he was quite that much of a rake. But the fact that his extremely intelligent and unconventional sister kept house for him helps me believe that he appreciated a clever, spirited woman.
Speaking of Clooney – that man can star in my May/December romance any day. He just gets better and better looking! And more and more charming. And does more and more good things for charity. Sigh…
Feb 20, 2012
1:44 pm
I LOVE imagining Cleveland as Clooney! I wonder what lucky lady would play his Frances?
Feb 20, 2012
1:51 pm
This is a fabulous story, Tessa. How clever Cleveland was to keep the wedding a secret for so long. I do wonder about Frances’s mother and whether she really imagined he would propose to her. How horrid for her if she anticipated that!
The May/December romance I’ve loved for ages is Georgette Heyer’s Justin, the Duke of Avon, and the French girl Leonie from These Old Shades. It’s such a wonderful story — villain-turned-hero, with intrigue and adventure (and lots of French silliness). I don’t recall precisely how much older the duke was than Leonie, but when I first read it as a teenager I thought he was shockingly ancient. So he’s probably 30.
Feb 20, 2012
3:48 pm
I really need to read These Old Shades! That’s a Heyer I’ve never read.
Isn’t it funny, how your view of these things changes as you get older? Another favorite May/Dec romance is the VonTrapps in “Sound of Music” – but now when I watch it, I find myself feeling sorry for the baroness! I know she was nasty at times, but she really did have great chemistry with Georg and found herself tossed over for some pretty young thing with a guitar. Sigh.
Feb 20, 2012
4:49 pm
You really must read These Old Shades, it is one of Heyer’s best I think. I put off reading it for ages because I’d read The Black Moth and I knew that Justin was a reworking of the villian in that so I just couldn’t see how he could be made a sympathetic character but then I read Devil’s Cub (which is my out and out favourite Heyer) and I softened towards him enough to give his story a chance.
Feb 20, 2012
6:45 pm
Oh, LL, I’ve never read Devil’s Cub! Can’t wait to now!
It occurs to me (as I write a post for a visit on Thursday to the Austen Authors blog) that Emma and Knightley are a May/December couple — she a mere twenty and he thirty-seven! Why don’t I ever think of them that way, I wonder?
Feb 20, 2012
9:44 pm
You must definitely read Devil’s Cub. The heroine actually shoots the hero at one part it’s completely wonderful!
Last summer I challenged myself to read all of Heyer’s romance novels and it was definitely a pleasurable way to spend my summer!
I always found Emma amusing because Knightley’s younger brother was married to Emma’s older sister so in my head he seemed positively ancient! Although I was 12 the first time I read Emma so I suppose 37 was positively ancient.
Feb 20, 2012
3:24 pm
When I read your post, Tessa, I thought of Celine Dion and her old hubby Rene. I can’t think of any May/Dec. romances in any of my books. My fav. first lady would be Hillary Clinton.
Feb 20, 2012
3:45 pm
oh, yeah – I remember seeing Celine and Rene on Oprah several years ago. Their romance does sound remarkably similar–wasn’t he her manager or vocal coach for several years?
Feb 20, 2012
7:02 pm
yep
Feb 20, 2012
6:07 pm
I love May/December romances! There is so much potential there for fun. I love Claudia Dain’s Jane and the Duke of Edenham, from Daring a Duke. She is quite merciless in poking fun at him and his “advanced age”- she is eighteen, I believe and he is close to forty. But he falls for her in the first moment he sees her, and no one else will do, even though she is proudly, defiantly American and he is an English duke!
My favorite White House couple is our current one. I love the Obamas. They are so down to earth, and yet, so refined and elegant.
My favorite first lady, though, is Hilary Clinton. Although, I think she’s nuts to stay with a man who cheated on her, she persevered through that entire ordeal with grace and pride, and never let them see her sweat. She is a strong, classy woman who has redefined the definition of “role model”. I just think she’s peaches.
Feb 21, 2012
12:11 am
Olivia, I haven’t read that Claudia Dain book, but it sounds delightful!
I really admire Hilary Clinton, too, but not even so much for her role as First Lady as for everything she’s gone on to accomplish afterwards.
Feb 20, 2012
6:11 pm
Tessa, that was so interesting! Great history story. I’m not crazy about May-Dec. romances. They kind of gross me out, LOL. I guess I remember being an 18 year old who got hit on by 40-something men and how completely inappropriate that felt. It conditioned me to go “ick.” But that’s just me! I’m sure it was very different in bygone eras, too.
Gaelen
Feb 21, 2012
12:13 am
I totally get what you mean, Gaelen! May/December romances can be swoony in the abstract, but in real life… I mean, if I look at my late-30s husband and try to picture him with a 19-year-old girl? Ick, indeed.
Feb 20, 2012
9:40 pm
I’m largely pro May/December romances, whether it be older hero+younger heroine or older heroine+younger hero–anything to stimulate delicious romantic conflict! As for my favorite First Lady: Eleanor Roosevelt. But my favorite White House resident will always be Alice Roosevelt Longworth, Theodore Roosevelt’s rambunctious daughter.
Feb 21, 2012
12:14 am
I love Alice Roosevelt! I totally thought about her while writing my first heroine, Lucy from Goddess of the Hunt.
Feb 20, 2012
10:42 pm
Love the post, Tessa! And I’ve enjoyed (and written) quite a few May/December romances of all stripes. As Gaelen says, there are some times when it triggers the ick factor but usually, I’m down!
Feb 21, 2012
12:16 am
I share your attitude – in the hands of the right writer, any pairing can be romantic!
Feb 21, 2012
7:03 pm
Great post, Tessa!
I honestly had no idea about Grover Cleveland and his wife. In my defense, I’m not from the US (English isn’t even my first language) and our professors did not teach us about them in our American history classes. *hides* It’s a shame because stories like this one can make history less daunting for some students.
As for May/December romances, I am going to pick JAL – What I did for a Duke. I like a witty novel with great characters and I had a lot of fun reading it.
Feb 23, 2012
12:04 am
Favorite first lady–Eleanor Roosevelt.
Favorite May-December book couple: Genevieve Eversea and Alexander Moncrieffe from Julie Anne Long’s What I Did for a Duke, published last year.
Feb 23, 2012
9:39 pm
I have mixed feelings about May/December marriages. I supposed it depends on the couple involved. I would think if the man is much older he becomes almost like a father figure. Whereas a couple closer in age would seem better suited to be friends.
Feb 28, 2012
3:03 pm
I loved this post! I never knew any of the details of the Cleveland marriage (like them doing ads?!) but I do recall teachers telling us he was the only prez to get married while in the White House. May/December romances always squicked me out but I think it’s more from a personal fear of imbalance of power in the relationship than from seeing age as a specific problem. My parents had about an 11 year gap (father older one) and yeah, even as a kid the imbalance was glaring.
Probably this is why my favorite first lady is Hilary Clinton. I love how she always says what she thinks and feels even when it means heavy flak and even hate will be thrown at her. I admired her no-fear attitude in politics and growing up she was probably one of the biggest influences of feminist strength because I could see her on my tv in real life! lol