Feb
My Bloody Valentine, or How Valentine’s Day Got Started
So you think you’re losing your head over your sweetheart? Well, I’ll see your smarmy Vermont Teddy Bear and raise you a beheading. SAY WHAT?? Oh, Happy Valentine’s Day, everyone (a little early).
Since the Great Holiday of Romance is nearly upon us, I found myself curious ~ proud History Dork that I am ~ about the historical truth behind St. Valentine’s Day and how all this got chocolatey-rosey goodness got started. Who was this Valentine fellow, when did he live, and how did he come to be the patron saint of this day of love? And did he really wear a diaper and go around shooting people with a bow and arrow?
Needing to know, naturally, I put it into The Google and could barely wait to come tumbling headlong into the Ballroom to tell you all what I’ve unearthed.
<Squawk! Beheadings Aren’t Romantic! Squawk!>
No, indeed, Albert, I quite agree. A stupid $100 Teddy Bear (and I’ve sworn to garotte my husband if he ever gets me one of these bits of clutter–CHOCOLATE, MAN, IF YOU KNOW WHAT’S GOOD FOR YOU)…as I was saying…the teddy bear is a far cry from the sentiments that motivated our Saint Valentine, who laid down his life for what he believed in.
Lady B: Ms. Foley, whatever are you on about today? Have you had too much of that horrid Colonial coffee you are always swigging?
Afraid so, dear hostess. I’m positively bouncing off the walls with it. But I can’t help it! I am eager to share with my fellow history lovers a glimpse into the world of Ancient Rome in the 3rd Century A.D. …
Lady B: Ahh, Italy! Now that Boney is quite thrashed, I plead every day with my Lord B. to convey me thither. How I long to feel the Tuscan sun warm my cheeks…
Egads, Lady B., you are waxing poetical.
Lady B: Isn’t that what Italy’s all about? Byron and Shelley are there…
Yes, in our Regency day, certes, but in the 3rd century, you had to be careful to keep your head about you.
Lady B: You’re going to fill my Ballroom with tingling Gothic horror, I presume? Go on then, if you must…
It was a dark and stormy night — no wait, scratch that.
It was a secretive yet joyous occasion as the Roman priest, Valentinus, stood before a small, hidden gathering of believers to marry a young couple in the early Christian church. WHEN SUDDENLY – Roman soldiers burst in and began wreaking havoc on them. The wedding guests scattered; the groom was injured in the fracas, the bride barely escaped ravishment, but the priest, ah, the poor, brave priest, Valentinus, was arrested. The year was 269 AD, and to be a Christian was a capital offence. (“DRAMATIZATION”)
Valentinus was a priest of the early Church who was helping Christians survive during the persecution under the Roman Emperor Claudius II.
Claudius, the villain in our story, was born 213 A.D. His parentage is not recorded. He served all his life in the Roman armies, fighting against the Goths, working his way up to become the commander of an elite cavalry force. Thanks to his troops’ devotion, he came to power during the chaotic rule of Gallienus. He was said to be one tough mo-fo, knocking the teeth out of a horse with one punch. (I suppose it tried to bite him?) It seemed he ruled his troops with an iron fist, and he brought this same sensibility to his rule when he became Emperor at age 55. His street name was Claudius the Goth.
His rule only lasted two years. He died of smallpox while arranging a campaign against the Vandals, and his younger brother, Quintillus, briefly seized power before also being replaced by the Aurelian, “Restorer of the World.” Claudius II was a middle-of-the-road persecutor of Christians, according to Church history. Aurelian, by contrast, led one of the ten great persecutions of the early Church.
Gallenius, his predecessor, by contrast, had had a tolerant view of the Christians, but the Roman Senate had grumbled that Gallenius had not been devout enough to the Roman gods. Thus, to gain approval, Claudius wanted to show himself as more attentive to the old ways, and always consulted the Sybilline Books before a battle. [Sybil as in the Delphic Oracle, those prophetesses of Apollo, also devoted to the 'great mother,' Cybele, and Ceres, goddess of the harvest.]
When Christians refused to give honor to Apollo & company, it seemed to the leaders that they were undermining social unity (Roman policy was generally tolerant/inclusive of the gods of the many, many cultures they conquered–to be otherwise would have been too difficult). They simply added more gods into their total population of deities as they conquered new lands, but the Christians would not go along with this.
True, the Jews didn’t believe in multiple gods, either, but they didn’t go around trying to spread their faith. The Christians did, and so the Roman authorities saw them as a bad influence. Even the ordinary folk were frightened that these nonbelievers insulted the gods like Apollo, Mars and Jupiter, and would bring down punishment on everybody if they were not rebuked. So, the Christians had to be made an example of.
Lions, tigers and bears, oh my–though the punishment they received under Claudius the Goth wasn’t anywhere near the viciousness of the grand-baddy of them all, Nero. To get the flavor of what had already been done to Christians under Nero, listen to the Roman historian Tacitus:
“Besides being put to death they [the Christians] were made to serve as objects of amusement; they were clad in the hides of beast and torn to death by dogs; others were crucified, others set on fire to serve to illuminate the night when daylight failed. Nero had thrown open his grounds for the display, and was putting on a show in the circus, where he mingled with the people in the dress of a charioteer or drove about in his chariot. All this gave rise to a feeling of pity, even toward men whose guilt merited the most exemplary punishment; for it was felt that they were being destroyed not for the public good but to satisfy the cruelty of an individual.” (Nero, pictured left)
Still, while Claudius II was a sweetheart compared to Nero, it was still a capital crime to be a Christian. The government could confiscate your property and threw your in jail, and then things got nastier from there if your still refused to give honor to their gods.
Into this alarming situation comes Valentinus, a priest who lives in Rome and finds a new round of persecution percolating when Claudius II seizes power. Legend has it he was caught marrying Christian couples, but one way or another, he was arrested in 269 A.D. and eventually brought before Claudius.
Claudius supposedly took a liking to him, but Valentinus went too far and tried to convert him. Claudius sentenced him to death. While in jail, according to legend, Valentinus healed the eyes of his jailer’s blind daughter. On the night before his execution, he wrote her a note along with this gift of healing, signed, “From your Valentine.”
Then the day came and it was time for his sentence to be carried out. But when beating with clubs was not enough to kill him, he was beheaded near the Flaminian Gate and is buried on the Via Flaminia, north of Rome.
Lady B: What a tragical history…!
The lives of saints are steeped in legend and obscured by the centuries, but how their stories evolve is interesting, in itself. For example, some say the great English poet Geoffrey Chaucer and his circle (mid 1300′s) had a hand in crafting the story of Saint Valentine as it has come down to us today.
How ever much of all this you do or don’t believe, archaeologists found a Roman catacomb and an ancient church dedicated to Saint Valentine, and in 496 AD Pope Gelasius marked February 14th as a celebration in honor of his martyrdom.
Today, Saint Valentine is the Patron Saint of engaged couples, happy marriages, love, lovers, and young people. He is represented in pictures with birds and roses. (Thanks to Wikipedia, www.Catholic.org, which has a full battery of saint bios, and www.EarlyChurch.org.uk for info in this article.)
So the next time you hear some cynic scoffing about how Valentine’s Day is a made-up holiday invented by the Hallmark Greeting Industrial Complex, remind them that LOVE is and always has been worth celebrating, whether it’s the One True Love of some ordinary person’s lifetime or the love that inspires a saint to lay down his life. Indeed, if LOVE is not worth celebrating with a special day all it’s own, I don’t know what is.
So, what are you giving the one you love for Valentine’s Day this year? Even if it’s not a spouse/lover, it’s a chance to let our dearest friends/family know we love them. Have you got anything special planned? If you do, please share. I have no idea what to get my husband…I don’t want to have to resort to a Teddy Bear… (aw, lol, they’re not that bad, I guess, but I can’t see paying $100 for the dang thing…)


















Feb 9, 2012
1:33 am
Hi Gaelen, … Lady B., [awkward curtsy]
That was truly fascinating even though I already knew the history. Thanks for sharing it with us and I love your little ditties that you threw in, like Imperial Dickhead, Nero! [laughing]
Valentine’s Day is just another day to me and my dh except when it falls on a weekend but I will make a special dinner for us, get him a card from me and from our 4-legged son, Marco, and probably some special sweet treat/dessert since he’s not allowed normally. He’ll get me a dozen red roses like he does every year and perhaps a card. He remembers and that’s all that really matters. : )
Btw, in Latin, the plural of Valentinus is Valentini. Yay! Doubt we’re related – Valentini in the Italian phone book is like Smith in the US! Just think it’s romantic.
Happy Valentine’s Day early!!
Feb 9, 2012
12:35 pm
With your name, this is definitely the perfect holiday for you, Amy!
Feb 9, 2012
1:08 pm
Oh, how fun, I didn’t think of that, Ms. Valentini! Lucky you! I didn’t realize that was a common last name for Italians. Very cool!

Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
9:31 am
I say Bah humbug to Valentine’s Day. I am happily single with no significant other to give me chocolates, jewels, roses, or even $100 Teddy Bears.
Now if I did have a special certain someone (hint hint Collin Firth) I would be all over this special day. I would make him feel like the only man on earth. He would get tools, game tickets, a special dinner with me for dessert.
The sweetest Valentine have ever received was from my ex hubby. He had all my friends and neighbors stop by the house and give me a rose and a note. By the time he got home I had a dozen roses, lots of notes, and he topped it off with some bling, a sapphire ring.
So for 2012 Valentines Day, I will be making VD cards for the sick kids in the hospital that I work at. Love is something that is best shared.
Feb 9, 2012
11:30 am
Susan, your ex did have a wonderful moment of romantic success at least that time. Your making cards for the sick kids in the hospital is wonderful. You’re right, it’s not about $100 Teddy Bears, chocolates or roses – it’s about sharing the love. I’m going to check into whether or not they have something like that at our hospital for next year. I love that idea. Thanks. You’re a sweet Valentine. : )
Feb 9, 2012
12:35 pm
What a wonderful way to spend the holiday, Susan!
Feb 9, 2012
1:10 pm
That’s a beautiful idea, Susan, and beautifully said.:) So thoughtful! Nice story about your ex, too. What do you do at the hospital? Just curious.

Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
1:11 pm
BTW, the kids at the hospital deserve the teddy bears! At least that would make sense–!
Feb 9, 2012
1:41 pm
I am an analyst at Texas Children’s Hospital. One of the departments has requested that employees create Valentine’s Day cards for the kids, so that’s how I have been spending my evenings.
Feb 9, 2012
3:33 pm
Sounds like a great job–meaningful, too.
Feb 9, 2012
3:31 pm
oh, what a lovely idea to make cards for the kids in the hospital!
Feb 9, 2012
11:50 am
“If LOVE is not worth celebrating with a special day all it’s own, I don’t know what is.” Yay, Gaelen! Your post is at once hilarious and profound. I am particularly fond of romance novels in which the hero or heroine agrees to lay down his or her life for the other. There is nothing so powerful, I think, than love that will sacrifice all for the lover’s welfare.
I’m nearly ashamed to admit that I’ve been preoccupied with convincing my son to actually make a Valentine’s card for each of his classmates this year (last year he gave everybody mini chocolate bars), so I don’t yet have an idea for a Valentine for my dh. Thank you for the inspiration, though. Now I think I know what I’ll do for him! Um… wait… I don’t mean I’m going to go lay down my life for him next Tuesday. Not precisely. I mean, there aren’t any Evil Emperors hanging around central North Carolina these days. At least I don’t think so. I hope. :}
Feb 9, 2012
1:13 pm
Thanks, Katharine! Hey, you never know who might be lurking in those N. Carolina forests.. lol. Yes, please don’t lay down your life for the dh, we want to keep you!

Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
12:38 pm
Great post, Gaelen!
My husband and I rarely celebrate Valentine’s day, but when we do, we love to go out to breakfast or lunch and try new to us restaurants.
And he knows, if he does feel like buying chocolates, exactly which chocolate store he should order from. (Martine’s in NYC, btw, in case anyone else is a fan of freshly made raspberry and dark chocolate)
Feb 9, 2012
1:18 pm
Oh YUM Sabrina!
Eric and I are going to try to make it over to the Phipps Conservatory (a botanical gardens with a huge Victorian glasshouse) where we had our 1st date and our wedding!
If anyone wants to take the online “tour” of this wonderful place, you can see it here:
http://phipps.conservatory.org/phipps-online-tour.aspx
That’s our tradition, and a dinner at The Century Inn, which was a coaching inn out here when western PA was the frontier, in the late 1700′s. It’s a neat place!
Somebody put their pix of it up on Flickr, if you want to see what an American coaching inn looked like in the area where George Washington started his military career. I think he had a pint here at some point…
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mcgervey/3975807088/in/photostream/
Feb 9, 2012
1:29 pm
Sweet idea, Gaelen, and very romantic. You certainly did get your own hero, didn’t you? : )
Feb 9, 2012
2:05 pm
O.M.G. that place is gorgeous! How very romantic!
Feb 9, 2012
3:35 pm
I’m glad you went to look! It smells heavenly inside. The Orchid Show in the winter is my annual favorite event there, and it’s coming up shortly!
Feb 9, 2012
12:53 pm
I will spend it with Mark Harmon watching NCIS and have some of my fav dark chocolate almond bark, from my fav Candy store.
Great history of this time of the year.. I wonder if the author of The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre read this bit of ancient history when writing this book. Talk about murder and mayhem..
Happy Valentine’s Day to you all.
Feb 9, 2012
1:21 pm
Kathleen, you may have to fight my mom for him, lol. Oooh, ahhh dark chocolate almond bark! WOW. That sounds great.
What’s the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre? It sounds familiar but I’m drawing a blank. When/where?
Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
1:32 pm
It is about the big Chicago Massacre back in the 30′s during prohabition and the fight beteween fueding Maffi lords Al Capon and Bugs Moran . It was made into a movie too..
Very Bloody for sure.
Feb 9, 2012
1:33 pm
Gaelen, the St. Valentine’s Day massacre was the 1929 murder of 7 mob members as part of a prohibition battle between two very powerful criminal gangs in Chicago. Al Capone’s gang vs Bugs Moran’s. It was named so because it happened on Valentine’s Day.
If you saw SOME LIKE IT HOT (the movie) with Jack Lemmon, Tony Curtis, and Marilyn Monroe, you’d be in the middle of it at the beginning. : )
Feb 9, 2012
1:56 pm
I love Some Like It Hot, Amy. Just thinking about that movie makes me laugh.
Feb 9, 2012
3:36 pm
Oh, thanks for the heads up. I remember hearing about that now. I have never seen a Marilyn Monroe movie–!
Feb 9, 2012
12:59 pm
Wow. Gaelen! I’m exhausted after reading about all those bloodthirsty Romans! I’ll never think of Feb 14 in terms of pink hearts again, and most definitely not teddy bears. As for chocolate, we don’t need a special day for that.
I’ve never liked the commercial aspects of Valentine’s Day. Like New Year’s Eve, a night I’m practically guaranteed to fall asleep before midnight, in my contrary way Feb 14 always seems the last night I want to go on a date. But I love the idea of having a day when we just celebrate love in all its manifestations. And my favorite way to celebrate everything is with flowers. Not red roses – I don’t like florists’ roses because they have no scent. A gorgeous bouquet of fragrant spring blooms is the way to go.
Feb 9, 2012
1:22 pm
Hi Miranda! I’m with you on the flowers. Tulips are my faves, esp. red ones.
I know–! We could give the Teddy Bears to the Romans for the Colisseum!!! What do you think??
Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
1:53 pm
I got my Mom a Whitman’s Sampler with a pic of a cat on the heart shaped box. She always likes Whitman’s. I don’t have a sweetheart, so Mom & I are each others Valentine.
Feb 9, 2012
3:27 pm
Aww, that’s sweet! Literally and figuratively. I think I will give myself Whitman’s for V-day, since I doubt Mr. Dare would ever think of it.
Feb 9, 2012
3:37 pm
That is sweet, Jamie. Especially if she shaares it with you!!
I always hope the box of chocolates comes with a “map” of what’s what in there, cuz like Forrest Gump says, You never know what you’re gonna get.
My luck, I always pick the yucky one in there that nobody wants, lol.
Feb 9, 2012
3:25 pm
Saint stories are always so much better than any of the other stories in Christianity. Guttings! Beheadings! Literal trial by fire! Love it. Bring on the gore, I say. Thanks for sharing, Gaelen!
I am proud to say that I have been with my husband for 10 years, and we have never once celebrated Valentine’s Day. I blame the influence of my foodie-Father, who refused to eat out on Valentine’s Day because the chefs were always overtaxed by starry-eyed lovers.
But in all honesty? It always seemed so forced. Bring me flowers on March 2nd. Not because it’s a day when you’re *supposed* to bring them, but because you *want* to. Give me a gift on February 10th because you saw it and thought of me. I vote, down with VDay. And up with love every day!
Feb 9, 2012
3:40 pm
Up with love every day! I love that!!
You know, Sarah, you bring up a good point…if Valentine’s Day puts pressure on EVERYONE to be romantic, it’s 100 times worse for Romance Authors because we’re supposed to be unusually romantic.
Well, I’m afraid the jig is up on that one, since none of us seems to have any idea what the hell to do for our men for Valentine’s Day LMAO.

Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
5:27 pm
Amen to everything you said Sarah.
Couldn’t have put it better myself!
Feb 9, 2012
3:30 pm
Valentine’s Day falls within a few days of Mr. Dare’s and my wedding anniversary, so we usually have one celebration for both occasions, on whatever day makes the most sense. And we’re not usually big gift people–we prefer to spend the money to go out for a nice dinner or to see a concert.
Sad, secret truth – last year, I bought my husband a Valentine’s care (or anniversary card?) and for one reason or another, never got around to giving it to him. I still have it and will recycle it this year.
And I call myself a romance writer! *hangs head in shame*
Feb 9, 2012
3:41 pm
Tessa, I feel your pain!!! I’ve done that! Though I think it was a birthday for him rather than V-Day. Still!
See message above…romance authors who can’t think of anything romantic in real life… LOL. Oh, the shame!!!
Gaelen
Feb 9, 2012
5:24 pm
Fascinating post Gaelen! I had a vague inkling that the history behind Valentines Day wasn’t so cheery and romantic, but I certainly didn’t expect this level of gore and bloodshed! Sheds a whole new light on the holiday for me for sure.
My exciting Valentines Day plans? I will actually be working, and then coming home to collapse. My favorite Valentines Day was one year in college when it was me in my PJs, a pint of Ben and Jerry’s, and P&P (the Colin Firth version, natch) on DVD. I swear I had a better time than my friends who had dates.
Feb 9, 2012
5:41 pm
Just popped in to say I quite enjoyed the Valentine’s Day history lesson. Since I am single, my plans will be to give my4-legged love a new toy and some extra dog treats, watch Firelight or Pride and Prejudice (another vote for the Colin Firth version), open a bottle of wine, and indulge in some Sarris candy. Thanks heavens we didn’t lose our Sarris candy factory!!
Thanks too for the reminder that I must get back to Phipp’s Conservatory. I haven’t been there in a few years and have never gone for the orchid show. I agree that it is the most beautiful and fragrant place! I used to go to The Century Inn every Christmas with friends and I haven’t done that in quite a while either. You’ve inspired me!
Feb 10, 2012
2:12 am
You’re treating yourself to something special on Valentine’s Day … good for you!! Everyone should be their own best Valentine cuz love starts from within. : )
Mar 17, 2012
7:16 pm
Somebody once said to me that the story of Valentines come’s off as a testament of history, that the faiths will always clash, and that religion is the downfall of humanity.
I reached a much simpler conclusion – that
Love is- and always will be- the essence of life.
Thank you for sharing that wonderful piece of writing, I do believe you could be a a wonderful historian in addition to the grand writer that you are.
A very late “Happy Valentines” to you and your family.