May
Saturday Salon: Wedding Cake
We have something of a bridal theme going on here at the Ballroom Blog at the moment, with two real sets of nuptials and a whole host of fictional ones coming up. (Is it just me, or do you imagine that Lady B has a whole cabinet full of truly alarming hats to wear to said weddings?)
In preparation for my upcoming nuptials, the mother of a good friend of mine has been sending me daily pictures of wedding cakes. These range from the glorious…
… to the truly insane:
My friend’s mother titled that last one: “When the Groom Has Input”.
Be grateful: I spared you the Satanic Hell-Mouth Halloween cake. (I kid you not.)
Naturally, all of this got me wondering about Wedding Cakes Past.
My friend’s mother informed me that the tradition of the wedding cake dates back to Ancient Rome, when thin wheat cakes were crumpled over the bride’s head to ensure fertility. (I have already told my fiancé that there is zero way he is mashing cake onto my head, fertility or no fertility. Buttercream is sticky.) According to various, probably unreliable internet sources, this cake ritual came along with the Roman legions to England, where the tradition developed of baking numerous small cakes for a wedding party, possibly piling them up and making the bride and groom attempt to kiss over them.
Is it just me, or has anyone noticed how many wedding traditions seem to tend towards making the bride and groom kiss in public? Rather like our modern tradition of clinking glasses to make the bride and groom smooch. You can just see ye olde groomsman elbowing his buddies and saying, “Hey! I’ve got an idea. Let’s make this pile of cake and then dare Aethelbert to kiss Hedwiga without knocking them all over! Betcha he can’t do it!” “Ha! If you think that, you don’t know olde Aethelbert. Betcha three goats that he can!” “I’ll take your goats and raise you a sheep.” “You’re on!” They were probably also drinking a little bit of ye olde malt brew at the time.
But I digress.
Wouldn’t you know it was (reputedly) those decadent French who first thought of icing those little cakes? While the French were playing with icing, back in England, the seventeenth and eighteenth century saw the bridal pie. Because, really, what doesn’t say romance like pie? A ring would be baked into the pie and she who found the ring would be, supposedly, the next to marry. Either that, or just lose a tooth from biting a ring baked into a pie.
That brings us to our era. (And by our, I mean the Ballroom.) Were there wedding cakes in the Regency? Absolutely. We have no less an authority than Austen on it. The following passage comes from the beginning of Emma:
The compliments of [Mr. Woodhouse’s] neighbours were over; he was no longer teased by being wished joy of so sorrowful an event; and the wedding-cake, which had been a great distress to him, was all eat up. His own stomach could bear nothing rich, and he could never believe other people to be different from himself. What was unwholesome to him, he regarded as unfit for any body; and he had, therefore, earnestly tried to dissuade them from having any wedding-cake at all, and when that proved vain, as earnestly tried to prevent any body’s eating it. He had been at the pains of consulting Mr. Perry, the apothecary, on the subject. Mr. Perry was an intelligent, gentlemanlike man, whose frequent visits were one of the comforts of Mr. Woodhouse’s life; and, upon being applied to, he could not but acknowledge, (though it seemed rather against the bias of inclination,) that wedding-cake might certainly disagree with many — perhaps with most people, unless taken moderately. With such an opinion, in confirmation of his own, Mr. Woodhouse hoped to influence every visitor of the new-married pair; but still the cake was eaten; and there was no rest for his benevolent nerves till it was all gone.
What was this cake that so distressed Mr. Woodhouse? William Henderson’s 1806 The Household Instructor provides the following recipe for bride cake:
Take four pounds of fine flour well dried, four pounds of fresh butter, and two pounds of loaf sugar. Pound and sift fine a quarter of an ounce of mace, the same of nutmeg, and to every pound of flour put eight eggs well beat up. Wash four pounds of currents, pick them well, and dry them before the fire. Blanch a pound of sweet almonds and cut them length-ways very thin; take a pound of citron, a pound of candied orange, the same of candied lemon, and half a pint of brandy. First work the butter to a cream with your hand, then beat in your sugar a quarter of an hour, and work up the whites of your eggs to a very strong froth. Mix them with your sugar and butter, beat your yolks half an hour at least, and mix them with the other ingredients. Then put in your flour, mace and nutmeg, and keep beating it well until the oven is ready. Put in your brandy and beat lightly in your currants and almonds. Tie three sheets of paper round the bottom of your hoop, to keep it from running out, and rub it well with butter. Then put in your cake, and place your sweet-meats in three layers, with some cake between every layer. As soon as it is risen and colored, cover it with paper and send it to a moderate oven. Three hours will bake it.
Fundamentally, we’re talking fruit cake, with lots of alcohol to help it keep. The cake would then be iced, in a way not all that dissimilar to ours, although their white icing would often have been egg-white based and flavored with rose-water or orange-water, two popular Regency flavor choices.
It’s nice to know that some things don’t really change. Here’s last year’s royal wedding cake, which was, yes, a traditional fruit cake under all that white icing:
Lovely, no? I could go on posting pictures of cakes (the good, the bad, the exceedingly ugly), but at my back I can already hear Lady B’s slippers hurrying near, telling me I’ve overshot my allowed post length.
So instead, I’ll just ask: what are the best– and worst!– wedding cakes you’ve seen? And what would your dream wedding cake look like? Also, what are your suggestions for ideal wedding cake filling combos?
















May 12, 2012
8:01 am
Interesting post. I was at a wedding last week of one my co-workers. Her cake was very simple. Tall, 6 layers, each layer having one of vanilla and red velvet. They did not have a bride and groom at the top but their initials. Creamy icing and flowers, real I might add, that started at the bottom and curved up the top. This was a Vietnamese wedding so on every table, there was a bottle of Hennessy to drink and take home if there were leftovers. Those people can party!
May 12, 2012
11:34 am
This goes to my First Rule of Wedding Planning– always have plenty of alcohol! (Preferably not baked into the cake.)
That wedding sounds like such fun, Lady Susan!
May 12, 2012
1:01 pm
Alcohol is very very important at weddings!
May 12, 2012
5:28 pm
The bottle of brandy to go sounds like a tradition I could really get behind.
May 12, 2012
5:31 pm
That sounds like an excellent idea.
May 12, 2012
8:35 am
Great post abd congrats, Lauren!
My wedding cake will be rotating layers of lemon-vanilla and chocolate (he insists, I am not much for wedding-cake grade chocolate cake …) encased in white buttercream icing with fresh berries along the side, and a fresh baby sunflower head on top (that suddenly sounds very gruesome …).
My best friend just married and her was a traditional English fruit cake for the third layer (a concession to her English mother) … weirdly enough, no one – not even her mother had that one … the other three layers were chocolate cheesecake, vanilla strawberry and marble.
May 12, 2012
10:55 am
So clever to have different cakes for different layers, then there’s no need to make the tough decision!
May 12, 2012
11:36 am
I second what Miranda said! Also, yay for fresh berries– having spent a lot of time with tasting platters, going through icing flavors, after a bit you just crave some fresh fruit.
May 12, 2012
1:04 pm
Yep, fresh berries are the best! My cake was three tiers of 2 layered white cake with a fresh cream w/ raspberries and blackberries filling. Icing flowers cascading down the outside. Not so dissimilar from the first picture in the post. The one thing I’m not a huge fan of is fondant on the outside of a cake. It *looks* beautiful but doesn’t taste so great.
May 12, 2012
5:33 pm
Fondant is a bit like cement for cakes…. We decided to go with buttercream instead. Not quite so easy to sculpt, but much tastier.
May 12, 2012
5:30 pm
Well, if given the choice between the other layers and the fruit case, Ammy, I’ll admit I would have forsaken the fruitcake as well.
May 12, 2012
9:29 am
I have never been to a wedding, where the wedding cake was anything but BEAUTIFUL!!!! In most cases it was yellow cake with white icing.
The only interesting thing was what happened to the cake after it was displayed. Going from my niece, Becca, who was 2 years old at the time, taking her finger to lick off the icing to my friend’s friend’s boyfriend being Mr. Tough Guy with his buddy and knocking the cake to the floor. When I asked, “Does this mean we aren’t getting any cake?” I got the death stare.
My favorite unusual cake is on Steel Magnolia’s – the Armadillo Cake. Made with Red Velvet cake insides and animal flesh color on the outside.
My niece, Victoria, me and my niece, Becca’s step daughter, Hannah, all have our birthdays near each other. We have made it easy on the family by all wanting one Red Velvet cake between the 3 of us. I have Steel Magnolia’s for a couple of things, one is that cake, which made Victoria and I HAVE TO try it and we liked it. The other one? When my Dad had his first diabetic fit, I used what they did in the movie, to help him.
May 12, 2012
11:38 am
Your friend’s friend’s boyfriend seriously knocked the cake over?? Please tell me this was after the official cutting! And that he groveled appropriately after.
May 12, 2012
1:05 pm
Omg! Knocked the cake over? O_O. I think I’d be very upset.
Actually I was upset because the facility we had the wedding at threw away the leftovers of my cake! I seriously spent the day after my wedding crying about this. lol.
May 12, 2012
2:33 pm
That does stink. Didn’t the facility KNOW that a bride keeps her cake in the freezer until the first anniversary? Besides you paid for that cake, wouldn’t you want left overs? GEEZE!!! I think I would definitely cry over that, too.
May 12, 2012
2:31 pm
Unfortunately not, that is why I didn’t get any cake. One of my friends moaned to me – did you really have to ask that? Then we left the reception BEFORE the crap REALLY hit the fan.
May 12, 2012
5:32 pm
Knocking over the cake reminds me of that great scene in Ghosts of Girlfriends Past. I loved seeing Matthew McConaughy look like such a complete jerk — however hot I think he is!
May 12, 2012
10:08 am
Great post Lauren!
Nothing better than waking up Saturday morning and looking at pictures of yummy cakes.
And congratulations on your upcoming wedding!!! What exciting news!!! May the planning be as stress free as possible, and may you and your fiancee have a wonderful day and life together!
Now, when it comes to wedding cakes, I automatically think of Charm City Cakes in Baltimore. I used to watch their show Ace of Cakes on Food Network all the time and was astounded by the marvelous and beautiful creations.
http://www.charmcitycakes.com/gallery/stacked/
I think the Bell and Black&White cakes are all simple clean, elegant and would be perfect for a wedding.
But check out some of their more zany crazy cakes. It’s almost hard to believe they’re actually cakes!
http://www.charmcitycakes.com/gallery
As for flavors, my cousin had a lemon cake at his wedding, which was very delicious. I think most folks stick with classic flavors like vanilla, yellowcake etc for wedding cakes because it’s got to feed a lot of people, and there are many types of allergies and sensitivities, so it’s easiest to go with basic flavors that most everyone can eat.
May 12, 2012
10:39 am
When my parents got married they ordered a German Chocolate cake in direct opposition to the normal white or yellow cake. Two days before the wedding the bakery called my mother saying, “You know your cake will be BROWN? Chocolate is BROWN!”. Obviously, my mother was aware of the fact that chocolate is brown, and the whole party enjoyed the german chocolate cake immensely, but to this day anytime any one has chocolate cake we all say, “Chocolate is BROWN!”
May 12, 2012
11:39 am
Catie, I love that! There’s nothing like familial catchphrases– especially obscure ones that cause other people to give you all strange looks. (My family has a few of those.)
May 12, 2012
5:33 pm
Ha! Wonderful story, Catie! I love silly things that stick as family jokes like that.
May 12, 2012
11:01 am
Great post, Lauren! Aethelbert’s weddding made me spew my coffee.
Being English, I of course approve of fruit cake. Glad to hear it has a long history. However, I’d like to put American butter cream icing on it. The royal icing (basically confectioner’s sugar, lemon juice and egg whites) used to decorate English cakes is great for sculpture but not so much for taste. Plus in a few weeks it hardens to something the texture of granite and will break your teeth. The fruit cake, meanwhile, is so soaked in booze and preserved fruits it’ll be good for years. There’s a tradition of keeping the top layer of the wedding cake to use as the christening cake for the first child.
I adore the Wedgwood blue cake in your post – so clever and pretty.
May 12, 2012
11:41 am
It does sound like the whole edifice is designed more for preservation than flavor! If the witch’s house in Grimm had been iced with that, Hansel and Gretel would never have gone near it.
May 12, 2012
5:35 pm
Likewise on the spewing of beverage (at this late hour, vitamin water) due to the medieval cakes-kiss bet.
May 12, 2012
11:19 am
Great post Lauren! Nothing better than waking up Saturday morning and looking at pictures of yummy cakes.
And congratulations on your upcoming wedding!!! What exciting news!!! May the planning be as stress free as possible, and may you and your fiancee have a wonderful day and life together!
Now, when it comes to wedding cakes, I automatically think of Charm City Cakes in Baltimore. I used to watch their show Ace of Cakes on Food Network all the time and was astounded by the marvelous and beautiful creations.
I think the Bell and Black&White cakes are all simple clean, elegant and would be perfect for a wedding.


As for flavors, my cousin had a lemon cake at his wedding, which was very delicious. I think most folks stick with classic flavors like vanilla, yellowcake etc for wedding cakes because it’s got to feed a lot of people, and there are many types of allergies and sensitivities, so it’s easiest to go with basic flavors that most everyone can eat.
But check out some of CCC’s more zany cakes. It’s almost hard to believe it’s cake and not the real thing, lol



May 12, 2012
5:35 pm
The post made me hungry!
May 12, 2012
11:19 am
Great post Lauren! Nothing better than waking up Saturday morning and looking at pictures of yummy cakes.
And congratulations on your upcoming wedding!!! What exciting news!!! May the planning be as stress free as possible, and may you and your fiancee have a wonderful day and life together!
Now, when it comes to wedding cakes, I automatically think of Charm City Cakes in Baltimore. I used to watch their show Ace of Cakes on Food Network all the time and was astounded by the marvelous and beautiful creations.
I think the Bell and Black&White cakes are all simple clean, elegant and would be perfect for a wedding.


As for flavors, my cousin had a lemon cake at his wedding, which was very delicious. I think most folks stick with classic flavors like vanilla, yellowcake etc for wedding cakes because it’s got to feed a lot of people, and there are many types of allergies and sensitivities, so it’s easiest to go with basic flavors that most everyone can eat.
But check out some of CCC’s more zany cakes. It’s almost hard to believe it’s cake and not the real thing, lol


May 12, 2012
11:21 am
Sorry for the duplicate post!! Technical difficulties this morning!!!
May 12, 2012
5:34 pm
Lisa, are those crayons really a cake? That’s amazing.
May 12, 2012
11:04 pm
Hi Lauren,
Yep, according to their website, it’s completely edible!!! It really is amazing-I don’t know how they do it!
May 12, 2012
11:23 am
Hi, Lauren- I hope your wedding is perfect. The best wedding cakes I’ve ever seen were my own. My bride cake looked like your first picture. It had handmade sugar flowers all over it, and it was gorgeous. But, my groomscake was the biggest hit. It was a huge round chocolate angelfood cake with white marshmellow icing with fudge drizzle and pecans. We came home the next day to have some, and it was all gone.
May 12, 2012
5:36 pm
They sound deliciously artistic and dreamy, susan!
May 12, 2012
11:48 am
When my daughter married, she designed her cake and presented her drawing to the bakery when we went in to meet with them, and sample some delicious cake (best part of ordering a wedding cake). I guess I shouldn’t have expected anything else from an artist. Each of the five layers was a different cake and filling combination.
May 12, 2012
5:37 pm
Yum!
May 12, 2012
1:10 pm
Love this post, Lauren! Best wishes on the upcoming nuptuals. And I love how much weddings are a theme of the Ballroom this year. I really like weddings and am so grateful to my Bff’s brother for obligingly getting married this summer so I have one to go to!
For some reason, I always associate white cakes with weddings. I think this must stem from some childhood association.
May 12, 2012
2:45 pm
Hi Lauren,
I wish I could get this thing to post a picture because I would post a picture of my nephew’s recent wedding cake. Their wedding was in Colorado on March 31st so they went with a bit of last of winter touch. The background of the cake was the palest of blues in color with white snowflakes and then attached were sparking blue and white snowflakes, three tiers and it was beautiful.
The worst wedding cake was a friend of mine who I won’t mention by name because her cake was so ugly. It was all chocolate with melted chocolate dripping down the sides and looked like a mountain of well, let’s just say you might find something similar steaming it a cow pasture. It was two tiers and the top tier was shaped somewhat like a moutnain which is why it had this awful look. It did taste good, I have to admit that.
The worst tasting one I ever had was gorgeous to look at but tasted like a paper plate. Blech!
Happy Mother’s Day to all the moms and Lauren, may your wedding be perfect and be the best day of your life. : )
May 12, 2012
5:38 pm
LOL, Amy, on the mountain of eh-hem cake. Awful indeed.
May 12, 2012
4:07 pm
I absolutely love eleaborate and interesting wedding cakes. One idea I came up with for when I have my own is different flavours for different layers because everyone likes different cakes! So a fruit cake, a chocolate cake, a Madeira sponge, and my personal favourite lemon drizzle
Here are some pretty cakes I love….

May 12, 2012
4:16 pm
You guys are torturing me. I’m on week 2 of a freakin” low carb diet here and I loooove cake. Ohh now I am jonesing for some airy light cake with wonderful buttercream icing!
Those pictured above are too pretty to eat! Mine had tiers and columns and flowers and cherubs in addition to a heart statue on top.
Can I just say I have a pet peeve about newlyweds smashing wedding cake into each other’s mouths? Who does that? Doesn’t anyone have any manners anymore? It makes me cringe. Perhaps because it’s a waste of a good piece of cake. ha ha.
I’m going to go away and sulk over a slab of green tea jello with splenda. argh. lol.
Lauren, keep us posted on your wedding happenings! We are all so thrilled for you, and Kate too!
Gaelen
May 12, 2012
8:49 pm
Gaelen,
I agree with you. All these posts about cake and I am on a no fat, low carb, minuscule sugar diet for the next 8 days. On the good side, I am eating better, but no cake.
Last weekend’s wedding they did not smash cake in each other’s face. A very polite shared bites.
May 13, 2012
7:55 pm
Thanks Gael! And I love the post Lauren! I too, have been inundated with cake pictures. but the best cake I ever saw was a groom’s cake, designed to look exactly like Wrigley Field. The groom was such a Cubs Fan, the happy couple even gave their son (when he arrived a couple of years later) the middle name Wrigley.
May 12, 2012
4:24 pm
I’ll see if I can get the pictures to work for me. I always have trouble with that. All these are from my idol, Martha Stewart. *g*
Perfect for a less formal, cute summer or outdoor wedding or other summer party event:
This one looks like Regency era Wedgwood designs!
May 12, 2012
4:25 pm
Dang, nope didn’t work for me. sigh. Ah well, if you want to see some good ones, just google wedding cakes martha stewart.
Gaelen
May 12, 2012
5:38 pm
Lauren posted one up top that looks like Wedgewood – absolutely gorgeous. Gaelen, Happy Mother’s Day tomorrow, you’re Bingley’s Mommy! : )
May 12, 2012
5:40 pm
Here you go Gaelen

May 12, 2012
10:52 pm
Oooh, gorgeous!
May 13, 2012
7:56 pm
Oh, so pretty!
May 12, 2012
5:56 pm
I giggled through this post, Lauren. (See above re. spewing as well.) Congratulations on your nuptials momentarily!! I look forward to seeing photos of your cake, dress, and everything!
I adored my own wedding cake, pictured below. It was deliciously elegant chocolate cake with a buttercream frosting and real flowers, and it did not come without great drama. In the last crucial hour of frenzied preparations before heading to the church (the ceremony which was to precede the party at my parents’ home), the French baker called in what can only be called a perfectly gallic snit, and proceeded to fill my poor mother’s ear with woe about his plight and pure disdain; the florist (a local artist), apparently, wished to place the live flowers on his creation *without his approval*. In short, he refused to allow it!
Recall, this was less than an hour before the ceremony.
My mother handed the phone to my groom. He is a native French speaker. Mr. Ashe then proceeded to butter up the buttercream creator, sympathizing with his indignation, shredding the poor florist’s character to tiny bits, and vowing that not a millimeter of the cake would be damaged by such a wantonly callous wench. Embraced by such wisdom and understanding, the baker released the cake into my groom’s possession.
The florist worked quickly, modestly, and produced this beautiful treasure. She will no doubt someday sing with the angels in Heaven. Not so sure where the baker will be then… tho if a man makes it to heaven based on the superiority of his cakes alone, he’ll no doubt be there too. I hope they don’t bump into one another. :}
May 12, 2012
10:53 pm
I am soooo late for the ball today, but I hope I’m in time for cake
May 12, 2012
10:59 pm
Argh, children hanging on arm – hit “enter” too soon!
Anyhow, these photos are so beautiful!
When I have time to kill, I love looking through the “Cake Wrecks” website for both the good and truly terrible in cakes, especially wedding cakes. I always feel so bad for the bride who requested this:
and got this:
Can you imagine? The bride sued, and good for her!
May 13, 2012
2:01 am
OMG!! This last one, oh my, what a mess. Maybe that’s what happened to the chocolate one from my friend’s wedding, at least I hope … looked very similar to this one but just imagine it all brown!! This poor bride.
May 13, 2012
2:13 am
I’m (or more my feet) are still recovering from the wedding of a cousin of mine I was attending yesterday. But I have to reply to this post – even if I’m not really full awake – now because we had such a nice wedding cake. It’s kind of tradition in our family that wedding cakes are not bought but instead homemade from another cousin of mine who happens to be very, very good at baking. Yesterday we had a huge heart-shaped wedding cake with strawberries on top and a yummi cream-filling with something that is called here in Germany Schaumkuss and is translated in my dictionary as chocolate marshmallow. (But in my opinion the translation is not correct so if you want to see a Schaumkuss you better google it)
May 13, 2012
2:15 am
well, my upload of the pictures didn’t work
can you please delete the upload link in my post?
May 14, 2012
10:14 am
So sorry the pictures didn’t work, Alex! But that sounds like a delicious cake. Congratulations to your cousin!
May 14, 2012
3:54 pm
My wedding cake filling was chocolate cake with peanut butter – it was soo good!
For those not wanting a rich cake, I also had a white cake with fresh strawberry filling.