Jun
Building the Duke
I’m sitting hunched over Lady B’s escritoire in the south parlor, worrying the feathery end of a quill pen between my teeth, a blank sheet of paper before me.
The orchestra is tuning up in the ballroom, and Lady B is tapping her fan on the arm of her chair in impatience. But I can’t be bothered with that. The ball will have to wait today. For there is a task at hand!
Like an aviary at a tropical menagerie, my sister authoresses of the Ballroom, all dressed for today’s ball, are a rainbow of silk and lace adorning comfortable seats across the parlor. They’re waiting quite patiently, and I feel a wild surge of grateful affection for them.
So, I suppose you’re wondering why I gathered you all here today.
Lady B: Undoubtedly, Miss Ashe.
Well, you see… (I clear my throat) I am currently embarking upon that most sacred and frequently unnerving project: Inventing My Next Hero.
Miranda: You poor dear.
I know! It’s always the best and worst part of beginning a new book. I simply adore creating the delectably perfect man for a heroine. But we all know what can happen if things go unexpectedly…
I peer around the room at them, hoping someone will pick up this cue.
Silence.
No one will look at me.
Finally—
Sarah: I never lose control of my heroes.
Lauren: (patting Sarah’s knee) Of course you don’t.
Kate: Me neither. My heroes never, ever behave in a manner I don’t anticipate.
Lady B chokes.
Sabrina: (chuckles) And I suppose Gaelen’s heroes never embark upon fisticuffs in ballrooms.
Gaelen: And Sabrina’s heroes never refuse when their mothers beg them to marry.
Tessa: And Miranda’s heroines never hide in broom closets.
The quill is now in shreds between my teeth.
This isn’t about heroines! At least not this time. It’s about heroes. (I take a deep breath.) My hero, to be precise. My first duke. There, I’ve said it. I’m writing a duke. And… well…
Lady B perks up.
Lady B: Well what, dear gel?
Well, I have a pretty good idea of what I want him to be like, but I’m hoping to design him so carefully that he won’t be encouraged to get out of hand when the time comes to set him loose on his heroine. As it were. Um. But you know what I mean. Anyway, I hoped you all would give me a few ideas for him. You know, sort of like a ducal brainstorming session.
They’re all grinning at me, but they nod.
Great! Okay, so here is what I can already tell you about him. He is—
Miranda: Tall, dark, and handsome.
Now why didn’t I think of that? (I give her a Look.) But yes. Very tall, with dark, thick, silken brown waves any woman would ache to run her fingers through. Oh, and strikingly beautiful green eyes that send ladies to their knees.
Sabrina:Yum.
Tessa: Ditto.
Lady B: Where is his estate, Miss Ashe? And are his legs acceptable?
His legs are gorgeous. Naturally. But in point of fact he hasn’t come into his title just yet. That’s to come. He’s the heir.
Lauren: Does he have a name yet?
Oh, yes! He is Lucian Andrew Rallis Westfall. Luc to his intimates.
I look around at my friends, feeling much perkier than before. I do have a hero already! I pop a chocolate biscuit into my mouth and take a sip of tea. But he needs more.
So, what else should I make of him so that he’ll be the perfect, docile fellow to fall helplessly in love with my heroine and treat her like a princess from day one?
Gaelen: You could give him some sort of noble task to perform that makes him outrageously honorable. Honor can sometimes keep a fellow in check.
Ah! Yes! Honor! (I turn back to the blank sheet and start scribbling.) He’ll have oodles of honor! And…?
Lauren: You could make that noble task a big secret that he can’t disclose.
Mm… That works. I’m rather fond of heroes with secret identities, after all. (I scribble more notes.)
Miranda: For that sort of thing he’ll need brains. He should be brilliantly educated.
You’re so right. (Dip into the ink, then back to the page, furiously writing.)
Tessa: Discipline in a man with a mission is always a good idea. What about making him a military commander?
Kate: Perhaps a naval captain?
Oh, I do like sea captains. And he did fight in the war. (I doodle a frigate in the margin.) War hero, check! Anything else come to mind, ladies? I can’t think of—
Sabrina: He should be an exceptional lover.
Easily done. (whispering to the page) Oh, Arabella is going to be so, so happy… (I push back my chair with an excited flourish of my pen.) Well, ladies, this is perfect. I’m so glad I asked you—
Lady B: Miss Ashe, Miss MacLean has not yet contributed.
Oh! Sarah, do add something!
Sarah: If he’s going to be a duke, he has to be arrogant.
Lady B: She is perfectly correct, of course.
But— but…
I totally didn’t expect this. I look around at the others for confirmation.
Miranda: Arrogant as an emperor.
Lauren: Without doubt.
Sabrina: Though, justifiably so.
Kate: With all that going for him.
Tessa: And men being how they are…
Uncomfortable silence.
You’re right. You’re right! (I flail my hand with the now useless quill.) But if he’s arrogant, he won’t be controllable!
Gaelen: Fraid not.
But then what can I do—?
An idea bursts before me like one of those big old movie star photo flashes.
Lady B: Miss Ashe, why on earth are you grinning like my great-aunt Hortense when she hired a handsome new footman?
Oh, don’t mind me, my lady. But you know, I think I’ve just come up with an excellent plan for keeping my duke-to-be in check until he meets his heroine. At that point I’ll leave it to her, of course. But before they become acquainted, all I need to do to control him is…
The ladies lean forward in their chairs. I smile innocently.
I will take him down a peg. Of course!
You know my penchant for tortured heroes? Well here’s your chance to do the torturing! What shall it be? How will I make this heroic, powerful Adonis suffer? Be imaginative. He has to be positively tormented by the time my heroine appears to steal — and perhaps even heal — his noble heart.















Jun 4, 2012
1:44 am
Hi Katharine, I’m thinking Luc sounds wonderfully delicious already but yes, I agree, if he’s going to be a Duke, he’s going to be trouble …
How about he returns with a war injury? Nothing too horrible -perhaps a slow-healing gash to his leg which causes him to limp thus making him self-conscious. Something his ego can’t quite handle. Add a scar that he fears any proper young lady might be disgusted by and I think he’d stay rather tortured and controllable for a while. : )
Jun 4, 2012
10:23 am
Oh, the fragile male ego of a man so exalted! A war wound is a great idea, Amy. But poor thing. You know, it’s awfully hard to torture these men I adore.
Jun 4, 2012
11:22 am
You described him as so gorgeous, I just didn’t have the heart to make it too horrible. I love a tortured man but I want it to be a torture that a woman’s love and/or acceptance will heal. If it’s too ingrained, it will always be with him and since we do want a HEA, it must be something he can say, “as long as she loves me, I can face anything.”
Jun 4, 2012
8:47 pm
Well, is it bad that I think…knocked down a peg and sea captain = missing a leg?
Jun 4, 2012
8:55 pm
Good heavens! That does leap to mind. :}
Jun 4, 2012
2:26 am
Emotional wounds are usually good for pages and pages of “torture”. AND…they never disturbe his great looks.
Jun 4, 2012
10:25 am
Ha! Yes, definitely emotional trauma preserves a man’s outward appearance, usually. He’ll definitely retain his melting smile, that’s for sure.
Jun 4, 2012
8:44 pm
This is very true.
Jun 4, 2012
4:30 am
I would think…Rejection.
Perhaps from his family? A love gone wrong in the past?
Nothing brings a man down than a ‘nay’ afterall
Jun 4, 2012
10:25 am
You’re so right, Noor. Great idea! Poor guy…
Jun 4, 2012
7:23 am
Well if he’s gone away to war that would suggest to me that he wasn’t the eldest son, so something must have happened to the eldest son. So here’s my tortured backstory;
He fell in love with some girl and thought she was wonderful and in love with him etc etc until he finds out that she is only using him to get closer to his brother because she is naturally a horrible girl who only wants to be a duchess. So Luc is filled with anger and as a young person tends to do directs it at the wrong person and fights with his brother telling him that he hates him before riding off to join the military.
Naturally whilst he’s away some illness/accident strikes and his brother is killed.
So now our hero is tortured both by his last words to his dear brother and the fact that women are evil and only interested in being Duchesses.
Jun 4, 2012
10:28 am
Oh, that’s fabulous, LL! A heartless hussy. I did something like that in When a Scot Loves a Lady, in fact, though the other way around with the girl trying to get at the hero’s younger brother whom she was in love with. When the hero discovered it… well, that’s pretty much the root of Leam’s torment! I do like that scenario.
Jun 4, 2012
10:34 am
Yeah I did love that storyline, especially the truth about Leam’s brother. It was heartbreaking but so good for creating a nicely tortured hero.
Also can I just say how much I love Luc’s name
Jun 4, 2012
11:00 am
Oh or maybe he could have seen his elder brother die and not been strong enough or quick enough to save him and joined the army to get stronger and quicker and save lives in the hopes of making up for his failure to save his brother. And he avoids all emotional attachment because he thinks he isn’t capable of protecting those he loves the way a man is supposed to.
Ah why can’t we live in a world populated by emotionally tormented Dukes.
Jun 4, 2012
8:58 pm
Oh, that’s just so sad! When a beloved elder brother or parent dies at the beginning, it always puts me in mind of Disney movies, LOL. They do know how to tug on those old heart strings.
And yes, I completely agree, it would be wonderful. Let’s all make a big wish on a shooting star, our birthday candles, and what have you. The power of positive visualization is amazing.
Jun 4, 2012
8:56 pm
Thank you, on both accounts!
Jun 10, 2012
10:38 am
This idea is wonderful. Let me expand upon it by adding– what if his older brother was murdered? Luc would be riddled with guild and consumed by the mystery and frustration of finding his brother’s killer. Dealing with that would certainly keep him from socializing overly much. This plot would add a bit of mystery and complexity to the story.
Jun 10, 2012
10:39 am
Or *guilt, rather. lol
Jun 4, 2012
7:25 am
Thank you for sharing some info about the new book you’re working on Katharine!
I’m so excited. Ooohh I am all aflutter just thinking about Luc and Arabella! lol
I’ve always been of the opinion that nothing does a number on you like emotional scars and trauma from your past. So perhaps he was betrayed by someone he loved and/or trusted? A family member, a former fiancee who then jilts him? Or maybe there is some deep dark family secret that he’s burdened with (perhaps he has a family member who suffers from a mental illness and he’s tasked with protecting that family member and shielding them from public scorn/shame?) The possibilities are endless!
Jun 4, 2012
10:31 am
Lisa, betrayal is so painful! I hurt for Luc just imagining it! Sounds ideal. *wicked smile*
As to mental illness, have you read Laura Kinsale’s Flowers From the Storm yet? It’s brilliant, and the treatment of the mentally ill in it is heartbreaking. It’s one of my favorite romance novels to date.
Jun 4, 2012
8:13 am
Luc, the Duke, is tormented from his past. As the “youngest” of twin boys he has a mark on his chest and slight deformity on his right hand, hardly noticible. Since he is the spare, he is not given the ample amounts of love from his parents. They believe him to defective. While at school, the other boys, taunt him with Luc, the Duke and Luc becomes shy and inward. On the eve of the twins 16th birthday, the father has a bit of a conceince and writes a letter, signed by him, witnessed by the doctor, his lawyer, the mid-wife, housekeeper, and other servants, all who were present at the birth and know the truth.
Since he is the “spare”, he joins the Navy and his father allows it. Upon his return, his father is gravely ill and tells him on his death bed to find the letter and all will be set to right.
I think if you tell Luc you know where the letter is he should be controllable. Oh and to make things even better, the “older” twin is evil and mean and likes to inflict pain on others.
Jun 4, 2012
10:33 am
Oh, Lady Susan, this is a great idea. Luc is in fact the spare. How heartbreaking this would be! And deathbed confessions really do mess up things royally, don’t they?
Jun 4, 2012
9:37 pm
Don’t forget to add in the young girl that likes Luc for Luc and falls in love with him. She doesn’t know he is a duke, just a ship’s captain with great legs.
She is headstrong, daring, and finds the letter by accident. The father truly loves Luc and wishes he could have done things differently. If you noticed, the mother was not witnessed to this letter because she is a mean woman who wanted to be a dutchess.
Jun 4, 2012
9:22 am
He has an illegitamate child from an early indescretion. He hopes she will love is little Emma, but he’s afraid to tell her.
Jun 4, 2012
10:34 am
I love the illegitimate child angle, and I love the name Emma. Great ideas, Susan.
Jun 4, 2012
11:36 am
Luc sounds like so much fun, Katharine — I’m glad we could be of help
Although I would have supposed that considering that he is a man of action and the sea, that Lady B did not insist he have his very own Albert, who could easily call him on his bullsh–… er, that is, on his malarkey.
Jun 4, 2012
12:22 pm
Ooh, what a great topic. Torturing characters is one of the most difficult parts of a writer’s job. It’s rough, but someone has to do it. *evil grin*
I’m all for making the origin of the torture something that he’ll have to face head-on later in the book. Where seafaring heroes are concerned, fire always gets a vote. Very few things strike fear in a seaman’s heart like fire, right?
Or maybe the truth of his “heroic deed” is different from what the world believes, and the guilt is eating his heart by small pieces.
Jun 4, 2012
8:51 pm
Oooh fire! I like that.
Jun 4, 2012
9:00 pm
I wrote a book like that once! It was my first Regency novel ever, and the hero had done something bad/good on the Peninsula during the war and was a complete mess. I cried for him.
Jun 4, 2012
12:30 pm
Wonderful post, Katharine – so much fun coming up with ideas for other people’s characters. And what great comments. Our Ballroom denizens are always so inventive.
My mind has fixed on your last line “I will take him down a peg. Of course!” In my opinion there’s nothing (aside from the heroine) that brings a hero to his knees like Embarrassing Female Relatives. I suggest he has six older sisters who all like to reminisce about things like what he looked like naked at the age of two.
Jun 4, 2012
8:52 pm
Haha! Family will cut any ego down to size.
Jun 4, 2012
9:01 pm
Fabulous idea, Miranda!
Jun 4, 2012
1:29 pm
I like Miranda’s idea, as it sounds the most amusing. However, my own suggestion would be a heartbreaking Secret that shows just how amazing this fellow actually is. I know you want him to be splendidly educated, but suppose he had to truly persevere to become so. It would take strength of will and more than a few clever tricks to accomplish this feat if he suffered from severe dyslexia, and could barely read or write.
Jun 4, 2012
9:02 pm
Wonderful suggestion, bookstorecat! In fact, I just read a novel with that exact set up. It was marvelous and I truly loved that hero. I’m not going to tell you whose or what novel, so if you read it you’ll be surprised when you get to the revelation.
Jun 4, 2012
9:39 pm
I think I know the book you are talking about! And it is GREAT!
Jun 4, 2012
2:09 pm
He caused some kind of scandal in a Ballroom (Not yours, Lady B!) and was sent into the Army to “grow up”. Now that the war is over, he still wasn’t grown up enough, so he was sent to India for a time. He earned an independent fortune in India, so he’s now back in Jolly Olde England on his own terms. Daddy-the-Duke has less control over him than before, but he’s all grown up now and a little teeny bit too serious and aware of consequences for his actions, so he needs a heroine who can remind him to laugh at himself once in a while.
Oh, and his legs are Fabulous due to some sort of exercise he took up in India.
Jun 4, 2012
9:03 pm
Oo, I like this hero, Susan! Nice.
Jun 4, 2012
3:24 pm
Awesome post. I love Luc already. Hmm, torment, torture, rack and ruin, sorrow and woe… there’s gotta be something that hasn’t been done. You have the bad luck of finding me in a sillier than usual mood, Katharine and Company. With that caveat… these might be amusing:
* OCD (obsessive compulsive disorder…flies into a frenzy whenever he sees dust on the furniture)… No?
* Gluttony (despite his fabulous bod, he’s in a constant struggle against the battle of the bulge. Hey why not? For me it would be a matter of “Write what you know”) But probably not realistic in an era before the invention of chocolate candy was invented,
* Seasickness? Bad career choice for a sea captain. He had to hang his head off the side at that one crucial moment when he should’ve been paying attention; alas, the ship ran aground and sank, and most of the crew perished, and he’s never been able to forgive himself. A fatal case of the megrims…
* He THINKS he’s a vampire? (Lot of that going around these days)…
Somebody shut me up. Hit me over the head with a large object, whatever it takes…
Affectionate regards,
Gaelen
Jun 4, 2012
9:05 pm
I’m going to use all of these — at once! He’s going to be a huge disaster and his heroine will have miles to trek (metaphorically speaking) to help him get back in order.
* He THINKS he’s a vampire? (Lot of that going around these days)…” HAHAHAHAAA! Ha.
Jun 4, 2012
10:13 pm
Lady Gaelen is in fine form today
Jun 4, 2012
3:26 pm
PS–Can I just ask, what’s the deal with all the cannibals these days? C’mon, people. Let’s have some standards here! What Is Going ON??
Jun 4, 2012
3:28 pm
Katharine, maybe Luc’s secret honorable dangerous work could be Zombie hunting, since Z-Day the Zombie Apocalypse is clearly just around the corner…
Jun 4, 2012
9:05 pm
LOLOL. One zombie hunter coming right up!
Jun 4, 2012
5:53 pm
For torturing, I like the idea that EVERYONE he has come to care for dies on him. He gets a kitten as a child and it gets killed. He has a girl friend and she dies. He finds a buddy that he can work aside when he is on that ship and he dies. So, he is afraid to love or even care again because he knows what will happen.
Jun 4, 2012
6:42 pm
Like they’re walking down the street and a piano falls on them… i see ur vision. Love it… (That’s actually a good idea)

Gaelen
Jun 4, 2012
8:53 pm
Hah! And the piano is made by ACME too.
Jun 4, 2012
9:06 pm
Piano aside (eh hem, Gaelen), this is a great idea, Jamie.
Jun 4, 2012
9:51 pm
Our tormented Duke:
Has 6 younger sisters, 3 sets of twins that no one can keep track of. They are 16, 14, 12. He no longer has any single friends as they are afraid he will try to marry them to his sisters.
Or
Every woman he falls in love with, marry’s the next man she see’s. Always the Best Man, never the Groom.
Or
He has great legs, but kinda on the short side. About 5’7″.
Or
While at a country fair he meets a young lass and they have a “pretend” wedding, only to find out 10 years later they are actually married.
Or
Can play the piano, better than all of his 6 sisters.
Or
As a sea captain, he is always getting lost. Refuses to stop and ask directions while traveling on land, can’t work a compass and can’t tell port from starboard.
Jun 4, 2012
10:12 pm
Lady Susan – what a positive orgy of wonderful ideas. Miss Ashe gets first dibs but I may come for the leftovers. “Can play the piano, better than all of his 6 sisters.” Ha ha ha. Does he also write poetry?
Jun 4, 2012
10:38 pm
So much tormenting, so little time….
Dec 29, 2012
2:45 am
[...] You may recall that hero, Lucien Andrew Rallis Westfall, the duke of Lycombe. You helped me invent him! [...]
Jan 7, 2013
2:05 am
[...] have been helped along by our wonderful guests. Some were born in the ballroom, and some characters have entirely come into being [...]
Feb 23, 2013
8:12 am
[...] We’re docked for the sennight at Môle Saint-Nicolas, known in the eighteenth century as the Gibraltar of the Antilles. It’s a really impressive spot: a port on a strait between Cuba and Haiti through which ships must pass in order to sail to Central America. The peninsula is marvelously fortified, and right beyond it is a huge crescent bay in which you could hide an entire fleet (if you had a fleet to hide, which of course Britain did in this era, including the HMS Victory, former command of the hero of the first book in my new Prince Catchers series, I Married the Duke, Luc Westfall, whom you lovelies helped create!) [...]