Sep
Saturday Salon: Favorite Plots
On this Labour Day weekend (I had to add the extra “u”, or Lady B would ban me from the Ballroom), what better way to pass the time than discussing leisure reading?
So come join me in my sylvan book arbor. Settle yourself into a comfortable imaginary hammock, under the shade of a tree, with a large pitcher of iced tea (or sangria, or another beverage of your choice). There’s a platter of chocolate chip cookies, big bowls of chips and salsa, and some celery sticks and dip for the virtuous.
Today’s topic? Book tropes we can’t refuse.
The other day, I rewarded myself for finishing my latest manuscript with a book I had been hoarding, Sherry Thomas’s Ravishing the Heiress. It was an arranged marriage plot. I love arranged marriage plots, from Joan Wolf’s best friends pretending to an engagement that they can’t get out of in The Pretenders all the way to the far extreme of strangers marrying as a business arrangement in Heyer’s A Civil Contract. I might be a little skeptical that such marriages always worked (I have one that doesn’t work in one of my own books), but I am fascinated by the way the pressures of the situation affect the way the hero and the heroine get to know one another.
Other plots that are like catnip to me? Anything with a governess in it (Nine Coaches Waiting, I’m looking at you!) and any book in which the Heroine Inherits an Old House. I’m not sure how I would feel about a governess who Inherits an Old House, since I prefer to take my plot tropes neat– or, even more muddling, a governess in an arranged marriage who Inherits an Old House– but, taken singly, I’ll read anything that incorporates one of those tropes.
Which plot types do you find irresistible?











Sep 1, 2012
6:29 am
Beauty and the Beast. I have always loved any spin on that story (and the Disney movie).
Sep 1, 2012
10:38 am
Oh, me too, Beebs! Love it. And I simply adored Eloisa James’s treatment of it in WHEN BEATY TAMED THE BEAST. It was fabulous.
Sep 1, 2012
10:59 am
Me three.
Sep 1, 2012
3:52 pm
Four!
Sep 1, 2012
7:58 am
I’ve always loved battle of the sexes stories (which is why JQ’s The Viscount Who Loved Me is such a favorite). It’s always so much fun when the hero and heroine match wits and go toe-to-toe with each other.
I hope everyone has a great Labour Day Weekend!
Sep 1, 2012
8:39 am
I’m a sucker for a good hasty marriage due to being caught in a compromising situation.
Some that stand out for me in that category are; Eloisa James’ Midnight Pleasures, Suzanne Enoch’s Meet Me at Midnight and, of course, Miranda Neville’s Confessions from an Arranged Marriage.
I think I mainly love stories like these and the marriage of convenience books because I like the acceptance of the fact that marriage isn’t just a Happily Ever After, it requires some effort after the big day
Sep 1, 2012
11:01 am
I also love stories that play out after the hero and heroine are already married, usually not by choice.
Sep 1, 2012
1:05 pm
Thanks, LL. It’s one of my favorite tropes too, and I love the other two books you mention.
Sep 1, 2012
9:40 am
I am a complete sucker for Series books that are completely connected. Ones where there is a group of friends and there is a book for each friend. That way I can also get to know what is happening with the other characters besides the H/H because really good books are those when you don’t want to leave the characters.
I like “poor soul” characters, who find love. The mousy girl, who gets the handsome hero. The scared in both body and soul man, who gets a gal who is worthy of him and sees past all the pain. Marriage of convenience tales are also interesting because you see the couple falling in love. I also like the stories of the characters who meet as children and then grow up to be together – either being part for years or the story of the girl who liked the guy, but he didn’t notice her until something happens.
Sep 1, 2012
10:41 am
I love stories of characters who meet as children or young adults, Jamie. Erin Knightley’s MORE THAN A STRANGER had a great twist on that. They were pen pals, and the letters were wonderfully delightful. Rachel Gibson’s TRULY MADLY YOURS is a very different sort of the same trope, and one of my favorite romance novels ever. In fact, it was a big influence on me when I wrote IN THE ARMS OF A MARQUESS.
Sep 1, 2012
1:07 pm
Have to add Loretta Chase’s Last Night’s Scandal to the “met as children and pen pals.” Especially since we saw so much of them in Lord Perfect.
Sep 1, 2012
11:03 am
Oh same here! Series are sooo much fun. (For authors as well!)
Sep 1, 2012
11:05 am
I can’t pick a favorite plot. I know, I know, not playing fair. But I do, of course, love anything with mistresses and courtesans!
Sep 1, 2012
11:56 am
I’m a sucker for blind heroes. I think it’s because of all those Little House on the Prairie episodes I watched as a little girl and the huge crush I had on Adam. I hate it if they miraculously recover their sight at the end of the book though because that seems like such a cop-out to me.
I’m also a fan of the Beauty and Beast trope but in reverse; the plain/mousy/plump/whatever girl gets the hot hunky guy. But of course I have conditions! No makeovers or diets that suddenly make her attractive to the hero. He has to discover how fantastic she is EXACTLY the way she is already.
Sep 1, 2012
1:08 pm
Great question, Lauren. all of the above. I’ll also add revenge plots (I know not everyone loves them), bet plots, and any plot where the hero and heroine are stranded together somewhere.
Sep 1, 2012
3:53 pm
I have to add best-friend’s-little-sister! I just love the tension when the hero is caught between loyalty to his friend and feelings for the heroine.
Sep 1, 2012
4:38 pm
Hi Lauren, you sound like you’re in a very relaxing spot.
I’m a fan of just about any kind of trope possible but do have a special affinity for hidden identities or mistaken identities – long time fan of Zorro! *wink*
Lauren, I’m working on a governess story right now that centers around a friends since childhood theme and an arranged marriage – throw in some miscommunications, prejudice, honor, a mystery father, a little incest and it’s packed with something to please everyone – I hope. [sending a prayer high to the publishing gods]
Happy September Everyone!
Sep 1, 2012
5:20 pm
I really love romances with a plain heroine. But she has to be feisty and strong inside. Definetly not a doormat. And the hero, of course, discovers the beauty within.
Sep 1, 2012
6:55 pm
I just finished Eloisa James’ latest “The Ugly Duchess.” I loved it, actually I read it twice, once as an e-galley and in its final form. So right now I’m in a retelling of a fairy tale mode. I think this is the best yet of her HEA series.